After Rajya Sabha washout, govt ready for debate on Gaza

Sushma Swaraj had opposed any debate on the issue arguing it is not primarily concern of Government.

By: Press Trust of India | New Delhi | Updated: July 17, 2014 8:20 pm
rajya-sbha The opposition contended that a “wrong message” has already gone out to the world about the “silence” of Indian Parliament on such a serious issue. (source: PTI)

Yielding to Opposition demand, Government on Thursday agreed for a discussion in the Rajya Sabha on Gaza situation on Monday but not before proceedings of the day were washed out over the issue.

Doubts, however, remain on whether the House will function even on Friday as the opposition was still not satisfied and wants discussion at the earliest.

The opposition contended that a “wrong message” has already gone out to the world about  the “silence” of Indian Parliament on such a serious issue.

The issue echoed for last two days consecutively in the House which saw a deadlock as the opposition persisted with its demand for an early debate while the government resisted strongly, arguing that any discourteous remark could affect India’s relations with Israel and Palestine.

External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj even wrote to Rajya Sabha Chairman Hamid Ansari, saying that the notices given by opposition members for a debate are inadmissible but her contention was rejected.

Ansari, however, did not give a ruling in favour of immediate discussion even, saying a date will be fixed for it in consultation with the government.

After the ruckus ensured washout of the proceedings of Rajya Sabha with opposition parties like Congress, Left, SP, JD(U) and Trinamool Congress remaining adamant, the government in the evening agreed to have a discussion on Monday.

Official sources said the debate will take place at 12 pm  on Monday.

“The issue is very serious. It is so serious that it figured even in the Declaration of BRICS Summit attended by  Prime Minister Narendra Modi. A wrong message has already gone out to the world by the silence of the Indian Parliament so far,” said CPI leader D Raja while making a strong pitch for immediate discussion.

Leader of Opposition Ghulam Nabi Azad also underlined the international importance of the issue while pushing for a discussion.

The issue had been mysteriously listed in Wednesday’s  business but could not be taken up as government opposed it.

Latching on to the fact that it had been listed, the opposition said no other matter can be taken up till this issue is disposed off.

The House saw a complete deadlock over the rules and  procedures ever since it met for the day, leading to three adjournments before Deputy Chairman P J Kurien called it a day just before 3pm.

The Opposition maintained that since the debate could not take place on Wednesday despite being listed in the business, it should be taken up on Thursday.

Kurien said the list of business is day-specific and so Wednesday’s business cannot be conducted on Thursday.

Before adjourning the House, Kurien asserted that a lot of arguments has taken place over the procedures and “the matter is closed now”. He then called Prabhat Jha (BJP) to initiate discussion on Rail Budget.

This triggered an uproar and some members trooped into the Well, prompting the Chair to adjourn the House for the day.

In his ruling, Ansari accepted the written plea of Leader  of the House Arun Jaitley that the issue be not taken up for discussion on Thursday and the government will communicate an appropriate date for the same soon.

“Accordingly, in view of the provisions of rule 177 read with the communication received from the Leader of the House, the short duration discussion on Palestine has not been listed in today’s agenda paper,” Ansari said.

Citing rules, he said, the “the subject having been already admitted, now requires consultations with the Leader of the House to fix the next date and time for discussion.”

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. S
    Subramanian Chandramouli
    Jul 17, 2014 at 3:53 pm
    Why the 'secular' opposition, which wants the Govt. to respond to/involve in Hamas-Israel conflict, did not demand so in respect of Shia-Sunny conflict in Iraq, where the casualty is more. Is it becquse such a demand will hurt (at least a part of) their 'vote bank'? Even in foreign affairs, these 'secular' parties play vote bank politics.
    Reply
  2. D
    Dinesh Singh
    Jul 17, 2014 at 2:56 pm
    Really? Have opposition MPs no other business to discuss? No local, regional and national issues where opposition can contribute? Amazing how they are dying to discuss and for what?
    Reply
  3. S
    S'pani
    Jul 17, 2014 at 8:10 pm
    We have lot of immediate internal issues to be tackled with, what is the urgency to discuss and to waste time in other countries issues
    Reply
  4. S
    Sachin jagade
    Jul 17, 2014 at 5:09 pm
    We support Israel. Strongly. It has a right to not only defend itself but also to go after the Jihadis. Opposition parties are raising a ruckus with an eye on their Muslim vote bank. Shame that the opposition has never ever raised an issue concerning the cution of Hindus in stan and Bangladesh. More majority consolidation will happen in India and the opposition will suffer more electoral setbacks. And on Israel, we need a friend in our own battles with the jihadis and would have no better a friend than Israel.
    Reply
  5. S
    Shyamal Ganguly
    Jul 17, 2014 at 4:28 pm
    If Israel has no rights to exist, then stan also does not. Both were created by the British/American conspiracy at the end of world war 2.
    Reply
  6. S
    Shyamal Ganguly
    Jul 17, 2014 at 4:24 pm
    Theme of the debate: "All Muslims of India support HAMMAS, All non-Muslims support Israel". What a waste of tax payers money that does nothing.
    Reply
  7. C
    Citizen
    Jul 17, 2014 at 11:34 pm
    Some of the parties/elected guys are behaving with out any justification in disturbing the august house for their own cheap pority sake. Can any one tell me how many nations are discussing this issue in their ruling houses??? Does it mean that we do not have any other urgent/important issues concerning our citizens and the nation for these people to solve??? except this??? Oh god give our elected guys some wisdom and save the nation. Jaihind
    Reply
  8. Load More Comments