For standing up to Education Minister, Kerala Dalit principal is shunted out

The transfer has triggered anger across the state and put the government on the defensive.

Written by Shaju Philip | Thiruvanathapuram | Updated: June 27, 2014 8:50 am

A dalit principal of a girls’ high school has been transferred, days after she apparently ticked off the state education minister for arriving late at a function in her school. The transfer has triggered anger across the state and put the government on the defensive.

The incident took place on June 16 when Education Minister P K Abdu Rabb arrived for a function at the Government Girls’ Higher Secondary School, Cotton Hill, Thiruvananthapuram three hours behind schedule. He was scheduled to attend the inauguration ceremony of an English club at the school at 9. 30 am.

When the minister did not turn up until 11. 30 am, principal K K Urmila Devi, who was waiting at the gate with the school students, assigned the reception duty to the additional principal and went back to her office for meetings. Incidentally, the 55-year-old principal suffers from a serious brain ailment, for which she has been undergoing treatment for the past four years.

When the minister finally reached the school at 12.30 pm, he was upset on seeing the gates closed. The gates were opened by the minister’s security staff.

Later at the function, the principal in her address pointed out that programmes attended by VIPs should be organised in such a manner that they do not disrupt class hours. “I didn’t criticise the minister. What I had raised was the concern about students losing their academic hours due to the failure of the organisers. The organisers, the State Institute of English, should have arranged the function accordingly,” she said.

On June 20, she got a showcause notice from the education department, seeking an explanation on why the school gates were closed when the minister arrived and why she spoke against him for coming late. Although the notice demanded a reply in 15 days, the department transferred her earlier this week. Devi, who was only a year’s service left and has been under treatment for brain fungus, was shunted out to a school 45 km from here.

On Thursday, the CPM-led opposition staged a walkout from the assembly for the second consecutive day, demanding that the transfer order be revoked. Climbing down from his tough stand against the principal, Chief Minister Oommen Chandy said she can move appeal and the transfer was not punitive in nature.

CPM legislator V Shivankutty, who raised the issue in the assembly, said the minister was showing pettiness by transferring the teacher. He asked whether the gates of the girls’ school should be kept open during the school hours.

Rabb said the transfer was based on an inquiry report, which said Devi failed in discharging her duties and maintaining school discipline. He said he had to wait at the school gates for some time before his securityman opened it. “I had sought apology for being late at the event. But the headmistress tried to blow up the issue in a manner insulting me,” he said.

Devi said she was targeted because she belonged to a Scheduled Caste community. “I am the first Dalit to become the principal of this school (one of the largest in Kerala in terms of students). Many PTA members could not stomach a Dalit as school headmistress. I got transfer to the school on health ground. It is cruel that a disciplinary action was taken without hearing my side,” she said.

Devi, who moved an appeal in the state administrative tribunal, said, “No one told me that a school headmistress should receive a minister at the gate.”

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. A
    Jun 28, 2014 at 12:30 am
    Shame on you Mr. Minister. You need to go back to school.
    1. J
      Joby Joseph
      Jun 27, 2014 at 4:01 am
      This is ridiculous. The minister has to step down.
      1. B
        Jun 27, 2014 at 8:02 am
        All politicians come late for functions. This minister must be sacked for the double mistake of dela arrival and acting against the prinl wrongly.
        1. B
          Bappi Tsangma
          Jun 28, 2014 at 12:36 pm
          As the Minister is powerful one, the Prinl needs to use all venues including her caste to get the Minister that it was his fault. A prinl is always a person of principles.
          1. C
            Jun 27, 2014 at 9:23 am
            This is the height of arrogance, typical of the politicians. They expect others to waste their time without questioning their callous behaviour. If the minister was going late why couldn't he have informed the Headmistress so that she did not have to wait at the gate for two hours? These days everybody has a mobile phone and communication was not a problem. It was an established practice to give the last posting before retirement nearer the person's home. So it was clear that the transfer was done in order to punish her. One hopes that Ind Exp would follow up the news to ensure justice done to the lady.
            1. d
              Jun 27, 2014 at 5:34 pm
              just imagine if this was gujarat!
              1. S
                Jun 30, 2014 at 6:36 pm
                It is a real shame for all Keralites to have such an as educ minister... time to protest and kick him out.. sakshara keralam.. mangatholi..
                1. G
                  Jun 27, 2014 at 6:48 am
                  dissatisfied with being out of power at the Centre only, Congress state governments are making all out efforts to ensure that they are voted out at local levels too.Congressmen want a Congress-mukt bhaarat more than BJP, apparently.
                  1. A
                    Arshad Peer
                    Jun 27, 2014 at 5:43 am
                    Sack the minister with immediate effect
                    1. K
                      Jun 27, 2014 at 6:14 am
                      Kids and children waiting hours together for VIPS should be banned. instead of maintaining punctuality,they show no guilty but feel every right as feudal lords.. this is the difference between foreign ministers or leaders and Indians. we don't learn good qualities from western countries,but only smoking, boozing etc.
                      1. L
                        Jun 27, 2014 at 5:25 am
                        he aint any VIP
                        1. C
                          Charlatan Hunter
                          Jun 27, 2014 at 8:36 am
                          Shameful that the incident took place. The prinl's caste has got nothing to do with it. It is just abuse of power. No reason why caste should be mentioned in this case.Does anyone remember kids becoming unconscious in UP while waiting for Amar Singh and Jaya Pradha. The state congress leader Rita ..whatever was screaming on the news how this was child abuse.
                          1. N
                            Jun 27, 2014 at 5:47 am
                            The ruling Congress always humiliates the poor and down trodden.
                            1. N
                              Jun 27, 2014 at 3:58 am
                              If it is true that the Education Minister arrived for a function at the Girls’ School three hours behind schedule, then his office factotums should have kept the school continually informed of the minister's dela arrival. We are living in the age of instant messaging systems. If the minister follows stone-age protocols of respect, especially when he is the guilty party, he is unfit to hold the post of Education Minister, and should be the one transferred - to permanent homestay. At the least, he needs to apologise.
                              1. P
                                Jun 27, 2014 at 5:29 am
                                Oommen Chandy's government is run by the Muslim League, The Muslim League in Kerala is a secular party and the BJP is a communal party. This is the atude in the most literate state of the country.
                                1. k
                                  Jun 27, 2014 at 2:33 am
                                  uneducated education minister of kerala is megallomaniac. he should quit and offer apology.
                                  1. R
                                    Jun 26, 2014 at 9:45 pm
                                    The minister should be sacked and the prinl applauded. How dare politicians ume that they are royalty and everyone must wait on and for them.
                                    1. H
                                      Jun 27, 2014 at 6:49 am
                                      fantastic country we have, this is the largest democracy in the world, does not matter whether she is Dalit or whatever, I dunno why that comes into the picture, what stupidity to start with. dont color every stupid act with caste, religion. When people vote based on case, religion, free TV, free this, free that, then this is how the elected will treat the people. first have self respect, then all will fall into place.
                                      1. V
                                        Jun 27, 2014 at 1:37 am
                                        Skin this minister alive, who the heck does he think. Congis just want appeat at the cost of justice
                                        1. Load More Comments