Black money: Just chasing it sends wrong signal about India, find out why

The chief economic adviser said that progress and development have to be assessed in many different ways including on health and education parameters.

By: Express News Service | Bengaluru | Updated: June 23, 2015 6:25 am
 black money, Arvind Subramanian, NDA government, india black money, Indian Economy, black money india, india news, nation news Chief Economic Adviser to the NDA government Arvind Subramanian

Merely going after black money could create wrong perceptions about India and it is more important to understand why black money is created and address those issues, Chief Economic Adviser to the NDA government Arvind Subramanian said here today.

“I don’t understand black money. Politicians spend a lot of time and money on it. What I would say is that the way to think about black money is as a stock problem and a flow problem,’’ Subramanian said on the sidelines of a series of talks on ‘Economic Survey: Taking stock of the Indian Economy’ that he has been delivering around the country.

Share This Article
Related Article

The whole agenda of going after black money — an election promise of the BJP later described as a jumla by its president Amit Shah — “could actually compound some of the perceptions about India,’’ Subramanian said after his talk at the Indian Institute for Human Settlements.

One of the problems addressing the issue of black money is that India’s tax system could be perceived as being arbitrary, the chief economic adviser said. “For example, our tax system is seen as somewhat arbitrary. The whole going after black money could play into that and I think we need to be very careful about that,’’ he said.

“Much more important thing about black money is to understand why do we create black money in the first place and address those things. To me, black money is more important in terms of what it signals we are doing — arbitrariness, tax rules, discretion, corruption, all these things. We need to be very serious about addressing them,’’ Subramanian said.

In his talk, he described macroeconomic conditions as positive and said that India will record growth in the current fiscal irrespective of whether growth was being measured by the old GDP series or the new GDP series. He, however, expressed concern over stagnation of export growth especially in sectors like IT services.

“The ratio of exports of services to GDP, after growing in dollar terms at a rate of almost 30 per cent for about eight to nine years, has now flattened out and may be even declining. That is really worrying,’’ Subramanian said. “For one percentage point growth of demand globally our exports have plumeted sharply,’’ he said.

“There is something going on on our exports side including services exports, IT exports which I think we need to understand much more. There is something fundamentally wrong in terms of our competitiveness. This is a challenge we need to be alert going forward,’’ he said.

On the scale and pace of reforms, Subramanian said: “India is not in crisis and the expectation of big-bang reforms is quite unrealistic. India, as you also know, is a vibrant democracy, frustratingly vibrant democracy,’’ he said.

“One of the things that I have learnt over the last few years is that for all the talk of centralization of power under the new government, the irony is how difficult it is to centralize power in New Delhi. Power is just completely dispersed not just vertically between the Centre and the state but also horizontally across institutions, across the bureaucracy and across regulatory institutions as well. So, actually, it is very difficult to think about big-bang reforms in India,’’ Subramanian said.

Any government must be judged on the basis of changes they are able to affect using levers they have complete control over and incremental changes in other areas, he said. One of the challenges before the government is in extending direct benefit transfers on the lines of LPG subsidies to other goods.

The first-mile challenge is to invest in IT infrastructure projects like Aadhaar to identify the beneficiaries and the last-mile challenge is to build on schemes like Jan Dhan and Mobile money, he said.

The chief economic adviser said that progress and development have to be assessed in many different ways including on health and education parameters and added that GDP growth has a huge impact on lives and livelihood as well.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    Jun 23, 2015 at 8:56 am
    These people are paid big money to toe the government line. They sell their degrees to tell lies. Do not believe in these % star people. Talk to a risk-shah wallah and he will tell you the real truth.
    1. Joby Joseph
      Jun 23, 2015 at 1:08 pm
      Bakth are completely silent. Doing yoga I guess.
      1. B
        Bijan Mohanty
        Jun 23, 2015 at 4:30 pm
        What is happening on Black Money is eyewash. The only medicine to curb black money is good , corruption free governance. Both BJP and Congress are so immersed in corruption that they can never reduce generation of black money. AAP being new party is trying its best.
        1. S
          Jun 23, 2015 at 1:26 pm
          Quote: "Ms. Sonia hi has several lakhs of crores of rupees in black money. Her daughter also must have not less than that. Pappu has got it everywhere abroad. All 65 years they were doing this." Unquote: This was the BJP weapon used very freely in all election meetings and campaigns by the party. Remember, when Mr. L.K. Advani was under the impression that he is going to be the party's choice for PM, he produced even a list of black money account holders in foreign banks abroad in which Ms. Sonia hi's name was also there. Later he regretted and removed the name from list. The question is how you can tell all those poor voters that the horse on which you were riding is a lame one and you cannot win the race ? You are the adviser to the government. Put up this suggestion to your Ministers to use an undo button on all your public speakers and party members so that the public be re-educated on the subject as you would like to.
          1. I
            Jun 23, 2015 at 5:22 am
            The congress has mastered and streamlined the science and art of stock and flow (streamlining) of black money. Just look at Karnataka today where no appointments are given or papers move until the minister/s and the secretaries receive their kickbacks in advance. When that is the state of affairs in the IT capital, feel sorry for people of other congress and other corrupt states where politicians have mastered the LOOT-ASANA.
            1. Load More Comments