After Fali Nariman, former SC judge K T Thomas questions Lokpal selection

Justice K T Thomas writes to PMO, asks why the government even needs a panel.

New Delhi | Updated: March 4, 2014 8:18 am
Thomas' move to quit the Lokpal search committee is the latest controversy over appointing the anti-corruption ombudsman. Thomas’ move to quit the Lokpal search committee is the latest controversy over appointing the anti-corruption ombudsman.

Days after Fali Nariman declined to be part of the process to pick India’s first Lokpal, the government suffered a second embarrassment in the matter — retired Supreme Court judge K T Thomas, who headed the search panel, quit, saying the committee lacked independence.

In a letter sent to the Prime Minister’s Office, Justice (retd) Thomas withdrew his “willingness” to head the search panel, saying, “Why there should be a Search Committee at all?… When the Selection Committee itself can decide on who should be the members of Lokpal…”

With Nariman and Thomas quitting, the eight-member search panel now has two vacancies.

MUST READ: Whose Lokpal

Sources in the government said Thomas’s resignation has placed the government in a difficult position, because the appointment of the head of the search committee needs the consent of the selection committee, of which Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh are members. With the PM away in Myanmar, the government has little time to convene a meeting before elections are announced and the model code comes into force — expected any day now.

BJP leaders said the Leaders of Opposition in both Houses were likely to write to the Chief Election Commissioner over the delay in announcing elections. In 2009, the code of conduct had come into effect on March 3. 

As per the Lokpal selection process, the selection committee comprising the PM, Swaraj, Speaker Meira Kumar, Supreme Court Justice H L Dattu (representative of the Chief Justice of India), and jurist P P Rao (the fifth member) must set up a search committee to shortlist possible candidates. However, the government has forwarded a list of 305 names to the search committee, asking it to pick a shortlist from the list.

Thomas has said that he had second thoughts after Nariman declined to join the search panel. “The current selection process would overlook the most competent, the most independent and the most courageous,” Nariman said in his letter, sent to the PMO last Thursday.

Thomas had written: “When I went through the Rules I have come to realize that the work of the Search Committee is to pick out names of persons from the list provided by the Central Government.

“I have reservations in accepting the Chairmanship of the Search Committee. I do not consider it worthwhile to travel such a long distance from my hometown Kottayam in Kerala far up to New Delhi and spend many days to make a panel from the list forwarded by the DoPT of the Central government. The Search Committee cannot make any independent search to find out the most deserving persons to be included in the panel.”

Thomas, who lives in Kerala, was picked to head the search panel comprising 7 others.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    Abhi
    Mar 3, 2014 at 11:35 am
    Mr . Thomas you could have waited for next govt to come
    Reply
  2. J
    jagrupdhillon dhillon
    Mar 3, 2014 at 11:39 am
    This corrupt govt.will never appoint an indipendent lok pal.
    Reply
  3. K
    K
    Mar 3, 2014 at 11:31 am
    What more proof is required to convince that the Lokpal enacted by Congress and BJP is nothing but Jokepal, as repeatedly stated by Arvind Kejriwal. I wish, Kejriwal and his team organize country-wide presentation of their Jan Lokpal to prove its efficacy, fairness and transparency in the Ombudsman's selection process and working (both to the investigators as well as the graft accused) with no government control, whatsoever.
    Reply
  4. P
    Pappu Italvi
    Mar 3, 2014 at 11:55 am
    Kudos to Sushma Swaraj & BJP for first exposing and protesting against this fraud lokpal search drama of Congress
    Reply
  5. S
    Sanjiv Sharma
    Mar 4, 2014 at 7:34 am
    The control is all under central govt. And Kiran Bedi has been shouting that it is a very good Lokpal and Kejriwal is creating a myth among innocent common man that it is a Jokepal.
    Reply
  6. S
    Sanjay
    Mar 4, 2014 at 1:09 am
    I am curious to know what Ms. Bedi has to say now?
    Reply
  7. V
    Vijay Ranade
    Mar 5, 2014 at 5:21 pm
    It is better if new Govt takes initiative to form this panel. I doubt if we can really have independent ,honest Lokpal in near future.
    Reply
  8. Load More Comments