3rd and foreign language: HRD opens to debate

In a detailed note on “themes and questions for policy consultations”, ministry has listed 13 broad themes for school education and 20 for higher education.

Written by Ruhi Tewari | Amitabh Sinha & Geeta Guptanew Delhi | Updated: March 19, 2015 3:13 am
Smriti Irani, German language row,German in schools, Sanskrit language, Kendriya Vidyalaya schools, Smriti Irani German row, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan, KVS, express news When the Board of KVS, headed by Irani, scrapped German as the third language in October last year, the minister had cited three-language formula and the Constitution.

In an apparent climbdown months after it replaced German with Sanskrit as the third language in Kendriya Vidyalaya schools, the Smriti Irani-led HRD Ministry is looking at how “foreign languages can be prescribed as an additional tool” in a “highly competitive world” and whether the three-language formula should be “debated”.

Both these issues are set to be taken up at a meeting of state education ministers and secretaries on Saturday to discuss the consultative process in formulating the new national education policy. In a detailed note on the “themes and questions for policy consultations” during the meeting, the ministry has listed 13 broad themes for school education and 20 for higher education.

When the Board of Governors of Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (KVS), headed by Irani, scrapped German as the third language in October last year (German has been kept as an additional subject/ hobby class), the minister had cited the three-language formula and the Constitution. According to this formula, schools should teach Hindi, English and one modern Indian language (preferably one of the southern languages) in Hindi-speaking states and Hindi, English and the regional language in non-Hindi speaking states. Introduced in 1968, this formula was reiterated in the 1986 education policy, as well as in 2005.

But in its latest note, under the head of “promotion of languages” in school education, the ministry has said that a “multilingual society recognises the importance of education in languages”.

Among the questions that have been listed are:

* In a highly competitive world, at which level and how can foreign languages be prescribed as an additional tool?

* What language would you like your children to learn in schools?

* What should be the place of Hindi, English and local languages in school education?

* Which language would be preferred as a medium of instruction in schools?

* Should education in mother tongue and multilingual education in schools be encouraged?

The note also emphasises the importance of “mother tongue-based” education. “While there are some interventions for appointment of language teachers and promotion of classical languages, there is no comprehensive scheme or language policy and we need to have inputs on this dimension,” it says.

The note says “there is a general perception that children learning through English-medium have an advantage over others while entering the world of work”.

In an indication that there may be a revision of textbooks, the note also questions if there is a “need to improve secondary/ senior secondary textbooks” and how many languages should be taught at the secondary/ senior secondary levels.

Another issue that is likely to be discussed is whether abolition of Class X exams has “reduced learning levels” of students.

For higher education, a question that has been listed is if universities should “include foundation courses on cultural integration” and if “Indology studies” should be a part of the curriculum.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. R
    Mar 19, 2015 at 8:23 am
    It should be English and your Mother tongue, all other languages should be optional at equal importance. No Hindi for Southern States, Hindi only for states that has Hindi as their main language.
    1. Abhijit Bhattacharya
      Mar 19, 2015 at 7:59 am
      An uneducated HRD minister with forged certificates along with a half-educated Prime Minister will ensure that our demographic dividend turns into a demographic disaster.
      1. A
        Mar 19, 2015 at 12:03 pm
        Why don`t you give the news in a single page, you continue the news and on the continued page there is only two or three lines. Disappointed!
        1. A
          Anurag Srivastava
          Mar 19, 2015 at 12:59 pm
          The current Commissioner of Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan was earlier the PS to Shri Kapil Sibal when the latter was the Minister of Science & Techonology during the period 2004-2009. Shri Sibal had fought Lok Sabha elections against Smt. Smiriti Irani from Chandini Chowk during the year 2009. This may be a bone of contention.
          1. P
            Mar 19, 2015 at 1:13 pm
            Dear HRD Minister, Ignore the fools, because their agenda is not country's welfare but they scream only to pull you down. Formulate the policy, learning both from traditions of Santan Dharma plus best practices around the world.You and your team is fully capable to synthesize best out of these two and formulate an education system that will produce not only good but great Indians. Don't be afraid of anything, take a step and implement.
            1. Load More Comments