With BJP raising ‘the enemy within’, silent opposition pushed to the wall

As the BJP tries to draw a broader polarisation between “us” the nationalists and “them” the anti-nationals/ Leftists/ Islamists/ political opponents of the Modi regime/ Indian Muslims, non-BJP parties can be said to be looking on, at best.

Written by Vandita Mishra | Varanasi/ayodhya/muzaffarnagar | Published:March 7, 2016 2:40 am
Kanhaiya’s arrest in JNU came just short of a month after the Dalit student committed suicide in his room on the Hyderabad Central University campus. Kanhaiya’s arrest in JNU came just short of a month after the Dalit student committed suicide in his room on the Hyderabad Central University campus.

THE CONGRESS, SP and BSP may speak up in Parliament, but on the ground, in Uttar Pradesh, they appear subdued by the BJP’s aggressive framing of the Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) issue as a shorthand for a resetting of political focus on the “enemy within”.

As the BJP tries to draw a broader polarisation between “us” the nationalists and “them” the anti-nationals/ Leftists/ Islamists/ political opponents of the Modi regime/ Indian Muslims, non-BJP parties can be said to be looking on, at best.

Share This Article
Share
Related Article

There is little or no attempt to challenge the BJP on JNU, either on its own ground, or by articulating the issue as one that involves freedom of expression, or the university’s autonomy.

In fact, the sharpest admonition to the Modi-led party and government on the JNU issue comes not from any of the BJP’s political opponents but from someone who could be said to preside over its prime political property — it comes from Acharya Satyendra Das, mukhya archak or head priest of the makeshift Ram temple in Ayodhya. But more on that later.

First, the Congress. The party that is generally unwilling and mostly slow to take the political initiative in UP, especially on “Hindutva” issues, is seen to be on the backfoot on JNU, ever since vice-president Rahul Gandhi dropped in on the campus to express solidarity with the protesting students.

In the “mandiron ki nagri”, city of temples, of Varanasi, the last time the Congress roused itself to a state of agitation, was, ironically, when it joined the BJP in marching with the sadhus, sants and religious groups in October 2015 to protest against the administration’s implementation of an Allahabad high court ban on the immersion of idols in the Ganga.

The arrest of Congress MLA Ajay Rai at that time, for alleged involvement in mob violence, continues to be uppermost on the Congress’s mind here, which has mounted no public mobilisation so far on the JNU issue.

“We have organised a signature drive and demonstrations on Ajai Rai’s arrest. He did no wrong. It was a consensus issue, both Congress and BJP MLAs walked behind the sadhus,” says Satish Rai, Congress district spokesperson and professor at the Kashi Vidyapeeth.

When the Congress in Varanasi does speak on JNU, it invites attention to a constricted space for manoeuvre: “Arrest the guilty in JNU, but leave those you don’t have proof against, and find out if the video is concocted,” says Rai. “It remains to be seen if this becomes an election issue, but the general sentiment of the people is against JNU,” says Ratnakar Tripathi, former all-India joint secretary, NSUI.

“It’s a sentiment you cannot avoid. People are hurt, they feel how can you raise such slogans. They want to know why the Modi government is not taking action against the students. Rahul Gandhi said there must be freedom of expression, but I feel it cannot include the right to abuse your father or your mother.”

The Congress’s sharpest contention on JNU skirts the issue: “The BJP is raising it only to divert from the fact that the Modi market is collapsing, his government is losing popularity even in his own constituency,” says Tripathi.

When Modi filed his nomination from Varanasi, a sea of people had turned out for him, and “it took six-seven hours for the procession to cover five kilometres,” recalls Tripathi. But now, “the BJP has to issue public appeals in order to draw in crowds when he comes here,” he says.

“Varanasi was a symbol of the Modi lehar (wave),” says Rai. “But his government has done nothing so far. Even the cleaning of the Assi Ghat was by private initiative, the government only tried to take the credit for it later.”

In Muzaffarnagar, Pankaj Agarwal, chairman, Nagar Palika Parishad, and the defeated Congress candidate in the 2014 Lok Sabha polls, sums up the Congress’s best hope: “Modi can be felled only by Modi, or by his own party, not many will listen to us here. It will happen. In India, nothing remains on top forever. Even Indira Gandhi lost power, and then swept back.”

SP leaders in Varanasi, Faizabad, and Muzaffarnagar articulate a much more pointed opposition to the criminalisation of slogan-shouting students and BJP attempts at a new polarisation. But they seem circumscribed by their supreme leader Mulayam Singh Yadav’s intervention in Parliament — Netaji spoke of “vaicharik bahas”, the contestation of ideas, but emphasised that “those raising anti-national slogans cannot be forgiven” and demanded “badi se badi sazaa (the strictest punishment)” for them.

In Faizabad, this has meant that SP “sympathisers” organised a meeting to counter the BJP-ABVP offensive and to demand JNUSU president Kanhaiya Kumar’s release, but officially, the SP stayed away.

According to Suryakant Pandey, former SP state committee member, who runs the “Shaheed Shodh Sansthan” which participated in the event, “The SP is neutral on the issue. I don’t think that is right. It cannot be anti-national to raise slogans”.

Vinay Maurya, district president of the SP’s student wing, who attended the programme, says: “I was there, but not as a representative of the party. I think my party should speak, this is an issue for the young. BJP-ABVP are spreading their lies through repetition, and if it takes two minutes for the BJP-ABVP to get their message across to the people, it takes us twenty”.

The JNU issue is “more dangerous than mandir,” says Pandey. Because “nationalism vs anti-nationalism” divides everyone and is the last resort of “tanashahi (the dictatorial regime),” he says.

BSP leaders and office-bearers say they await Behenji’s “nirdesh”, when asked about JNU. “Behenji speaks on everything, we follow her,” says Avnish Kumar, mandal coordinator, in Varanasi. In Muzaffarnagar, Abhishek Chaudhary, former vice-president of BSP’s district unit, explains: “Our party does not speak on these issues. We made no statements even when so many people died in the riots here.”
By all accounts, Mayawati, who has spoken clearly and strongly in Parliament on the controversy surrounding the suicide of Dalit student Rohith Vemula in Hyderabad University, is yet to visibly lay down the party line on JNU.

In UP, then, it would appear to be left to Satyendra Das, mukhya archak or head priest of the makeshift Ram temple in Ayodhya, to warn the BJP that “vish failega”, the poison will spread, if it politicises the issue.

The BJP, he says, “will make it (JNU) an issue if they feel they stand to gain from it politically, and because Rahul Gandhi went there”. But that would be “chhoti aur galat soch”, small and wrong-minded. The JNU issue “should not be taken forward, projected or spread politically,” he says.

The acharya is certainly no advocate of freedom of expression: “If asking for the country’s dismemberment, or praising Afzal Guru is not anti-national, then what is? Language that hurts the nation is desh droh” and the students must be punished by law, he says. His insistence that the law, not politics, take its course on JNU contrasts conspicuously with his position on the demolition of the Babri Masjid: “There was never a masjid there, only a mandir”.

Satyendra Das’s criticism of the BJP’s politicisation of JNU is only a welling up of his deep bitterness over what he sees as the party’s abandoning of the grand Ram temple project due to its political compulsions: “They say we must wait till we get 370 MPs, a two-thirds majority. The PM can do it, but he is not interested. The BJP is insulting that which brought it to power,” he says.

Yet come to Ayodhya to hear the warning bells toll on the BJP’s attempts to work up “desh bhakti” into the new “mandir”.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. S
    Sri
    Mar 7, 2016 at 6:53 am
    The Indian media needs to understand that the democracy in India works. Instigating the youth to create chaos in the name of freedom of expression will only result in unnecessary mayhem. For all its faults India is the safest country for Muslims and Hindu's alike and they have lived together for centuries. The media should start to support the development program for India to thrive into the next centaury.
    Reply
    1. S
      Strategy.for.Elections
      Mar 7, 2016 at 1:53 am
      Amit Shah should take leverage of the KANHAIYA incident and strategize election campaign around that. He should declare everybody as anti-nationals other than brahmins. Then, only brahmins will be eligible to vote and results in all consuencies will be 100% BJP win.
      Reply
      1. D
        Ding Dong
        Mar 7, 2016 at 8:43 am
        They are silent because they sende the country's mood and know the pressues for what they are.
        Reply
        1. T
          The.last.item.will.scintilate.you
          Mar 7, 2016 at 2:19 am
          In the 2 years, GDP IMPROVED FROM A MERE 4.5% TO 7.9%. No country's GDP IMPROVED 3.4% WITHIN 2 WEEKS(TWO WEEKS ONLY). 99.99% of people are above BPL as the BPL BAR HAS BEEN LOWERED SINCE ALL FOOD ITEMS OTHER THAN COW MILK ARE DECLARED NON-EDIBLE. HEAD OF INDIAN STASTICAL INSUTE REMOVED TO IMPLEMENT THE FRAUDISTICAL AGENDA. INDIAN POTION WILL SOON BE DECLARED AS 99% MUSLIMS AND REMAINING 1% CHRISTIANS, AFTER ANNEXING STAN AND AFGANISTAN, IRAN( FOR SMRITI IRANI), IRAQ, ISRAEL(AKAND BARAT, REMEMBER). NEXT 3YEAR AGENDA: BUILD A TEMPLE FOR ADULT MALE SHEEP(RAM). AFTER THAT A TEMPLE FOR ADULT FEMALE BOVINE(COW). AFTER THAT A PERMANENT MEMORIAL FOR BRAHMINISM!
          Reply
          1. K
            Kj Kj
            Mar 7, 2016 at 2:26 am
            If RAM( see dictionary for official meaning) temple could not be built, CAN A COW TEMPLE AT LEAST? Hahn.....? Any help here?
            Reply
            1. H
              Hari
              Mar 7, 2016 at 7:52 am
              JNU is breeding ground of terrorists.
              Reply
              1. I
                IML sood
                Mar 7, 2016 at 8:47 am
                O my country men and women.It is always that majority community's misfortune that we get traitors here who always undone our efforts to unite and wipe out these anti national elements. Even one can find numerous fake names and morons of hidden ideny hurling all sort of abuses on majority community which after 60 years of Cong. role has found some voice under this strong and dedicated Govt.Once again these elements want to create confusion so be on guard and be ready to hit them hard.
                Reply
                1. I
                  IML sood
                  Mar 7, 2016 at 4:54 am
                  Pity is that many people like the writer of the article think their own narrow definition for nationalism is suited for and to every Indian. The thinking of such maroons is always narrow and for that reason incidents like JNU happen.and irony is that we don't want to learn any lesson resulting anti national forces raising their head which have been pampered by previous Cong. Govt.for long 60 years. There are many like CPM/CPI/JDU/RJD/AAP/NCP waiting to exploit the situation for their own vote bank gain. Shame on such anti nationalism thinking
                  Reply
                  1. L
                    Lunatic
                    Mar 7, 2016 at 10:49 am
                    The Congress and left loonies will be wiped out if they open their mouth any futher. They know this very well now and have zipped up. However media recordings are available for the next elections. There is still time left, but no amount of media support can make the langoti Indian believe that the prince is NOT naked.
                    Reply
                    1. P
                      Paul
                      Mar 7, 2016 at 1:30 am
                      The opposition has stopped BJP from functioning. BJP in power is one heck of a chance that India can improve and conquer poverty. But will the opposition let it happen. So far they have put every hurdle. If the Indian electorate has any sense they should see it through and make sure that Congress never comes in power.
                      Reply
                      1. M
                        MyTake
                        Mar 7, 2016 at 4:37 am
                        5th column replacing column one!
                        Reply
                        1. M
                          MyTake
                          Mar 7, 2016 at 4:32 am
                          Organise international seminars at JNU to discuss human right violations in stan in Baloochistan and other places to see how Afjal Gurus come in to show their support!
                          Reply
                          1. M
                            MyTake
                            Mar 7, 2016 at 12:24 am
                            Unless Modi Team is given 100% both in LS and in RS India's future is doomed. The fight won't be with arms but time will simply take over India and others just have to wait for there share! The Congies and Lefties have brought India to such level from where it hardly can walk - just maintaining status quo is seen to be great achievement!!
                            Reply
                            1. P
                              Punit
                              Mar 8, 2016 at 7:29 am
                              with these type of biased articles, only Indian express is losing its credibility. In first para itself she has written BJP is against Indian Muslims. What a shame? Even agenda driven journalism has its limits.
                              Reply
                              1. R
                                Raje
                                Mar 7, 2016 at 7:17 am
                                I-E only finds one or the other way to bring down NDA and BJP. This is everyday circuit and drama for IE. Nothing new. We all people should remember that something is really hurting these so called I-E, HT, NDTV, AAj tak and such media outlets that they spend 20 hrs a day tarnishing BJP. PC Chidambaram u turn of Ishrat, PC Chidambaram son and his 40k crores of property empire, Mummi and pappu in NH scam trying to gulp doen 2500 crores worth property for mere 50 lakhs.....aren't these important points to discuss??
                                Reply
                                1. T
                                  Thomas
                                  Mar 7, 2016 at 7:47 am
                                  There is no doubt. The enemy within are Congress, Communists CPI and CPIM, JDU, RJD, SP, JNU, etc., who are openly supporting terror elements such as Afsal Guru and Yakub Memon who wanted to destroy the nation. And the media wing of the terrorists appear to be The Indian Express, The Hindu, India Today, NDTV, etc. With so much anti national activities by these elements, the terrorists across the border must be feeling jobless.
                                  Reply
                                  1. A
                                    ak dev
                                    Mar 7, 2016 at 10:16 am
                                    Barkha, Rajdeep, Rahul, Vandita, Ravish all are GADDARs as they support GADDARS. All NDTV's journalists being pro-Kanahiya is not by chance but by design. Do Hindu rightist have no freedom of speech? Or all freedom of speech is reserved for leftiy and Congee GADDARS!
                                    Reply
                                    1. A
                                      ak dev
                                      Mar 7, 2016 at 10:25 am
                                      Over a period, the GADDARS have built a media network that work day and night to give color to statements coming from Hindu Rightists. To counter these GADDARS it's need of the hour to create a counter network of media. Hindu Rightists have also to work towards to cut off O2 to the GADDAR media houses.
                                      Reply
                                      1. A
                                        ak dev
                                        Mar 7, 2016 at 5:11 am
                                        The GADDARS may rejoice that they have invented Kanahiya to hide behind him. Earlier they had poped up Kejriwal in Delhi. Their tactic is throw mud and run away. However, it has woken up peace loving patriots and given danger signals to them. The energised patriots will not hesitate to use non-peaceful means if the government failed to contain GADDARS who think that Modi is afraid of taking on them due to loosing support from a section of Indians.
                                        Reply
                                        1. A
                                          ak dev
                                          Mar 7, 2016 at 10:27 am
                                          This GADDAR must be taken to siachin and dumped there.
                                          Reply
                                          1. A
                                            amit
                                            Mar 7, 2016 at 5:43 am
                                            Pressutes and secularist cought in its own Web.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments