Why do only SIMI men escape in MP: Opposition questions escape and encounter

Digvijaya Singh wondered whether it was a “coincidence” that in jailbreaks in Madhya Pradesh, “the only who have escaped are ex-SIMI people”.

Written by Manoj C G | New Delhi | Updated: November 1, 2016 3:32 pm
bhopal encounter, bhopal jailbreak, simi, simi activists, simi activists killed, bhopal encounter, simi activists killed, AIMIM, Owaisi, Arvind Kejriwal, congress, bjp, simi encounter, india news The Congress also referred to an alleged video of the encounter which has surfaced. (Source: ANI photo)

The Congress, the Left parties and other Opposition parties have questioned the alleged escape by eight men accused of being SIMI activists from Bhopal prison and their killing in an encounter by Madhya Pradesh police. AICC general secretary Digvijaya Singh said it was curious that only SIMI activists escape from jails in Madhya Pradesh and demanded a judicial probe.

WATCH VIDEO: Bhopal Jailbreak: 8 SIMI Activists Killed In Encounter

The Congress also referred to an alleged video of the encounter which has surfaced. Congress leader Manish Tewari told The Indian Express: “The purported video which has surfaced in the public space raises very disturbing questions as to whether the encounter was genuine or fake. It also raises the equally pertinent question with regard to the alleged jail break. Under those circumstances an inquiry by a sitting Supreme Court judge to establish the veracity of the events as they unfolded would be the only pathway to substantial justice.”

Digvijaya Singh wondered whether it was a “coincidence” that in jailbreaks in Madhya Pradesh, “the only who have escaped are ex-SIMI people”. In 2013, seven members of the SIMI had escaped from a jail in Khandwa [three of them were among those killed Monday]. “In both jailbreaks, it is only the accused from the SIMI (who have) escaped. Why not others? This is quite a coincidence,” Digvijaya said.

WATCH VIDEO: Find Out What National Crime Records Bureau’s Prison Data For 2015 Reveals

He demanded a judicial inquiry. He said it should also be probed whether they escaped or were made to escape as part of a plan. “The chief minister has ordered an inquiry by the NIA which has got a director who has got a second term of extension…so we don’t trust him. So we demand a judicial inquiry into this,” Digvijaya added. Asked whether he believes the episode was planned, he said “I wouldn’t be surprised.”

Asked why, he said “SIMI and Bajrang Dal and RSS are two faces of the same coin. I have always held them. One incites Muslims, the other incites Hindus.”

In Hyderabad, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi said, “The Home Minister of Madhya Pradesh says that these undertrials were armed with spoons…. People run away from prison after assassinating a guard and they only have spoons. So, to any normal person, this theory is unbelievable.”

CPM general secretary Sitaram Yechury said, “There should be a proper judicial inquiry, not an inquiry by the NIA. How did the jail break take place? Because various questions are being raised. So let there be a judicial inquiry to ascertain the veracity.”

Senior CPI leader D Raja too demanded a high-level judicial probe. “It has raised several questions about security in jails. And even about the jail administration. It cannot happen just like that. They say there was an encounter. The question is whether those who had escaped from the jail were in possession of fire arms… All this raises very serious questions. And unless there is a high-level judicial probe, which should go into all these aspects… There will be questions. Whatever the BJP government in Madhya Pradesh is saying is not enough.”

He said the central government should ask the state government. “How did such a serious security breach take place and what led to such an incident?”

AAP’s Arvind Kejriwal raised the killings on Twitter: “This is very serious. We demand an SC monitored investigation.”

With PTI in Hyderabad

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: November 1, 2016 1:49 am
  1. B
    BRIJ
    Nov 1, 2016 at 5:42 am
    The time is ripe when the top level bureaucrats and other directly involved officers are taken to task for not doing their jobs diligently. The incidence of Pathankot intrusion in air force base, attack on brigade Hq at URI and many such incidents including the current jail break do raise , a question on the integrity of our own people who are responsible for the safety of this nation. One can see the standard of vigilance on the streets where the security personal are positioned and their alertness. In this country Sr. officers are always busy in pleasing their masters so that they get promotions and post retirement benefits.
    Reply
    1. A
      Anil Sabaji
      Nov 1, 2016 at 2:30 am
      Why the Congies question government why only SIMI escape from jail. They should ask their creation SIMI about it. Those who believe in law, will face it. Those who know how the law is going to deal with them will either accept or try to run away. This should be a new precedence in handling jailbreaks. Anyone who run away from jail will be killed.
      Reply
      1. A
        asdasd
        Nov 1, 2016 at 6:05 am
        The contention of y 0 ur argument is false as far as this article and instance is related. The team of officers who killed these guys in retaliation were anyway going to get post retirement benefits enled by their appointment. Y0 u mean to say that officers took orders from govt. directly to kill these culrpits, if needed? . . . . Even if this is the scenario, what wrong did the legislator do, if he has done so? what is these guys would have planned some big attack on crowd . . you would have again blamed govt. and legislator . . about security personnel positioned and their alertness . . . . yes y 0u are partly correct about streets, but it does to apply to jails ... and jails are not open streets. please avoid such r@n dom f @rts in c0m mnets.
        Reply
        1. A
          asdasd
          Nov 1, 2016 at 4:47 am
          hahaha . .opposition is day by day becoming ret @rd like ra ga . . . now they can also say that the guard which was killed, was actually faking his duty and gave a fake resistance .. after that the guard himself asked the 8 guys to kill him . . . and the other guard who was just injured was pro-simi . . . . . like simi , congi should be banned for on of sedition and provocating divisive forces and playing religion based politics . . . . .but those standards .. congi can also advocate hafuse saeed if he ure to brainwash the mob for voting congi . . . how can congi party stoop to such levels to gain votes and chair the corrupt engines!!
          Reply
          1. A
            asdasd
            Nov 1, 2016 at 6:19 am
            you are correct that we are heavily relying on moral character of the legislator and as of now the power has not corrupted to an extent that they will grill any om men like y0u and me and encontr us . . . . but yes these guys deserved it. Dev faddu need to suck up to mns goons and he is soon to be paying price . . by the way. . if AWF rejected 5C, does it mean that kajo did not pay incur any loss?? . . less likely . .mns would want it through theater operators anyways . .
            Reply
            1. N
              NAVIN ASTI
              Nov 1, 2016 at 6:57 am
              It seems Diggi feels to have become a widow as the Jail-breakers,killed in the encounter are non-Hindus.CPI,CPM are crying just because these people who have become Martyrs in their eyes have been killed in the encounter.Such great courageous people(who can break jail and kill a cop),worthy of Bharat Ratna according to Congress,JDU,CPM,CPI,and AAP have been killed in police encounter.These mentally converts have no sympathy for the cop,killed while performing his duties,as he was killed by their dear ones.What a fall is there my countrymen? The same nuisance-valued COMMUNAL lot go silent when majority community suffers such incidence.Majority community has to be alert to defend itself against such evil forces,ESPECIALLY DURING ELECTIONS.It is in the interest of Nation that people like Digvijay are not given importance by Media.They wept in the past for Batla-house terrorists,remaining ignorant about martyrdom of Mohanchand Sharma.If they are having so soft corner,their leaders should be ashamed of taking security cover from armed forces..
              Reply
              1. K
                Kaliyug
                Nov 1, 2016 at 12:51 am
                Those working against India and its interests are the SIMI activists, the government should not spend time or money explaining its position on terrorism to the opposition, The Muslims need to behave like humans if they want to get justice,
                Reply
                1. Z
                  Zinat Ali
                  Nov 2, 2016 at 6:23 am
                  Dear Joseph, Choose between getting killed as unsuspecting innocents or Killing those misguided terrorists, before they strike. It is a case like Israt Jahan, for which so many minority sympathisers have spoken, but eventually what stood ?
                  Reply
                  1. Z
                    Zinat Ali
                    Nov 2, 2016 at 6:23 am
                    Ed, Choose between getting killed as unsuspecting innocents or Killing those misguided terrorists, before they strike. It is a case like Israt Jahan, for which so many minority sympathisers have spoken, but eventually what stood ?
                    Reply
                    1. J
                      Joseph
                      Nov 3, 2016 at 12:17 pm
                      Dear Zinat, The question is not about terrorist getting killed; in a way its good..but the Questions are how come they escaped such a well guarded prison? and from where did they get weapons? How come they go weapons and not transport to run away...? and only these 8 escaped?
                      Reply
                      1. J
                        jayaram
                        Nov 1, 2016 at 3:01 am
                        they are terrorist why congress and communist sympathy
                        Reply
                        1. K
                          kvl
                          Nov 1, 2016 at 6:37 am
                          IT is not a question of how opposition is symphathising with terrorists. By their stupid words they Yechuri, diggi, (KEJRI JOINED OR NOT) is demoralising the forces. danger to the security of the country and encouraging one section for destruction of the country. Why only SIMI escaped is ridiculous.will they tom tom to others? Foolish doubts After all they are convicts not innocent ones.There is a limit for opposing the government but stoop to such a heinous atude which destabilise the country.better to shut up their dirty comments.
                          Reply
                          1. N
                            NBR
                            Nov 1, 2016 at 1:24 am
                            What else can be expected from the Opposition political parties whose sympathies always lie with terrorists for cheap vote bank politics. Some have even disregarded the probe even before it started. THEY WANT EQUALITY IN BREAKING OF PRISON WALLS. As they will not even condone the brutal killing of Head Constable on duty by the SIMI men, let us offer our condolences for the parted soul and his family.
                            Reply
                            1. M
                              Mohammed Al-Mubarak
                              Nov 2, 2016 at 10:48 am
                              Dig V Singh may have connection with terrorists, just like he was a sympathizer before
                              Reply
                              1. U
                                undefined
                                Nov 1, 2016 at 12:01 pm
                                Dig V Singh asked the Muslim terrorists to escape.
                                Reply
                                1. U
                                  undefined
                                  Nov 1, 2016 at 12:03 pm
                                  Muslims want Caliphate.
                                  Reply
                                  1. S
                                    Sheik Mohamed
                                    Nov 1, 2016 at 1:08 am
                                    How can some persons escaped with spoons try to shoot security guards/policemen? What they want to hide from public?
                                    Reply
                                    1. S
                                      subraman
                                      Nov 1, 2016 at 3:56 am
                                      You did not ask how they killed the policeman.
                                      Reply
                                      1. S
                                        surojeet
                                        Nov 1, 2016 at 5:03 am
                                        Opposition is Right. These DEMOCRATIC FREEDOM FIGHTERS Should be Declared martyrs, a day should be declared a national holiday and each should be given Bharat Ratana.
                                        Reply
                                        1. E
                                          Ed
                                          Nov 1, 2016 at 7:47 am
                                          Issue is not the killing of the undertrials.Greater issue is whether we are heading into a right wing dictatorship.There are a number of incidents which lead us to believe that we indeed are heading down to that frightening sink.Let us start from Haryana jat agitation.Mobs roamed the streets burning property ,pulling out pengers from their vehicles and raping their women.Haryana was at a standstill for days together.But did the law enforcement fire pellet guns at the rioters ?A big no.Look at Kashmir instead of using water canons and tear gas pellet guns are fired to kill ,blind and maim small boys who are throwing stones.Decision is easy to take because they are muslims.A man is killed in his house because someone says he had slaughtered a cow.Later goat meat from his fridge miraculously becomes bovine flesh and the victim becomes a criminal.The no of killings reported from across the country of minorities and dalits have become a common fare lt;br/gt;.And the 'nationalists'are happy that after a long time a govt.has come in power which allows them the freedom to dispense street justice to any one who does not agree with them.Now the judiciary which was the refuge of the oppressed is being undermined and sought to echo the executive master the first muscular prime minister.Press in general has become an echo chamber for the jingoistic nationalists.Electronic media is mostly in a psychedelic hyper trip.I for the first time in my life voted for a person our prime minister because he talked of development of the country and not about religion caste or other divisive issues.But it seems that he has reverted to the same divisive agendas which his party advocates.War mongering,trashing the opposition,driving the weak in the corner.lt;br/gt;National highway 5 was washed out during the rain,where I live but our MP has no time for us.People who have houses next to highway are developing respiratory diseases but if one raises these issues one becomes antinational.Central govt employees are taking more bribes lower courts and the police corruption is at its peak.Prime minister by delegating his authority to the lumpen foot soldiers of his party is doing great injustice to the country and his legacy.
                                          Reply
                                          1. E
                                            Ed
                                            Nov 1, 2016 at 12:45 pm
                                            You are just being emotional and defensive.Also you have medieval mindset.This prime minister came on the promise of cleaning up the system and helping India to develop at breakneck speedstead he seems to be in election mode all the time.Every Man kee Bat gives new slogans.But where are the actions on the ground?In seventies some admirers like you took offence when INDIA IS INDIRA was laughed at now the same kind cannot stand criticism of our SUPERMAN prime minister. By the way Muslims never ruled India.It was Mughals who ruled a few major cities and the local rajas paid tribute to them to rule their terriorydia was a subcontinent like europe.Concept of nation state is just three hundred years old one respect you are right we indians are corrupt and this reflects upon the govts.we elect and defend.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments