Why disclose surgical strike proof, it’s against national interest: BJP

BJP maintained that demanding proof for the armed forces’ action would be against national interest and national security.

Written by Liz Mathew | New Delhi | Updated: October 12, 2016 6:24 pm
 surgical strikes, india pakistan strike, india attack pakistan, border tension, narendra modi, details of surgical strike, CCS, border security, BJP, arvind kejriwal on strikes, kejriwal want strike details, national interest, indian express news, india news, latest news India’s armed forces had launched “surgical strikes” along the LoC on terrorist launch pads operating in PoK on the intervening night of September 28-29

WHILE Prime Minister Narendra Modi chaired a meeting of the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) to discuss the security scenario in the wake of India’s surgical strikes on terror launch pads along LoC, the ruling BJP said Wednesday there is no need for releasing any evidence as being demanded by some.

BJP maintained that demanding proof for the armed forces’ action would be against national interest and national security. Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and some Congress leaders have urged the government to provide proof of the strikes to counter what they call Pakistan’s propaganda questioning the authenticity of the operation.

WATCH VIDEO: Parrikar: Credit For Surgical Strikes Goes To Army And 127 Cr Indians

“Why should we disclose video clips and other proof? How can we make Army secrets public? It is a question of national security and it will be against national interest,” said BJP national secretary Shrikant Sharma.

Sharma pointed out that in the past India had submitted evidence for the Mumbai terror attack and Pathankote attack. “Has anything happened? What action Pakistan has taken against the culprits? How long will we keep giving in to their demands? Now, we will respond only through action, not through words or evidence,” he said.

Read | Surgical strikes: Bodies taken away on trucks, loud explosions, eyewitnesses give graphic details

WATCH VIDEO: Those Seeking Proof Of Surgical Strikes Not Loyal, Says Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar

This comes the day The Indian Express, speaking to eyewitnesses across the LoC, reported on their graphic accounts of the strikes: short, intense fire in Dudhnial; loud explosions; damage to property; five or six bodies of suspected jihadists being loaded on trucks; attack in Leepa and near the military camps along the Katha Nar stream that empties into the Neelum river.

Minister of State for Home Affairs Hansraj Ahir said the Army would have some evidence and they must have handed it over to the Prime Minister. “The Prime Minister can use his discretion on whether it should be made public or not.”

India’s armed forces had launched “surgical strikes” along the LoC on terrorist launch pads operating in PoK on the intervening night of September 28-29. However, Pakistan denied any such operation and said that only two of its soldiers were killed in the cross-border firing that took place during the night. With the AAP and some Congress leaders demanding for evidences for the strike, the BJP has condemned them saying it would demoralise the armed forces.

WATCH VIDEO: Surgical Strikes: Eyewitnesses’ Accounts Validate India’s Claim Of A Lethal Strike


Sharma slammed the Opposition political leaders for raising questions. “This debate, originated from the other side of the border, is not good for the country or its interests. The Opposition leaders’ demands have just given fillip to Pakistan to raise questions,” he said adding that the neighbour’s attempts would be futile as the BJP-led government has succeeded in isolating Pakistan at the international level.

Hansraj Ahir said raising questions on the operation conducted by the Armed forces is equal to “humiliating” them. Some reports quoted Ahir as saying that the Army had handed over the video clips to the government.

But when contacted, he told The Indian Express: “What I said was that Army must have handed over the evidence to the Prime Minister and it is up to the PM to decide on whether they should be released or not.”

He said the Army so far has gone by the procedure. “The laid down procedure has been followed. The DGMO briefed the media about the surgical strikes. That was the right thing to do. Earlier, written documents were submitted to the government. Now that there is so much technology upgradation, video clips could be there. If there were clips, the Army must have submitted it to the Prime Minister,” he said.

Ahir said the US had not released video clips or any other documents on the killing of Osama bin Laden. “Usually, such things do not go public,” the minister said.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. S
    Oct 21, 2016 at 3:04 pm
    Credibility of Armed forces was never questionable. The politicians opened their big mouths and invited doubts. Forces proved their capability and raised the sagging morale.
    1. A
      Anil Bhadula
      Oct 8, 2016 at 12:26 am
      It is shame on the part certain politicians asking for proof. They do not understand the sensitivity of the issue as it could lead to opening the secrecy. Surgical Strikes video is nothing to do for information of public, it's useful for our Trg purpose for further surgical strikes. The learned people also after proof is disgusting. Our Brave Army is facing all hurdles and we all sleep, including the subject guys. In my opinion, Govt should not release the video of surgical strike because stan want to collect all crucial information about this operation and strategy. if Govt release this video then our enemy will see the tactics, weapons, skillsets, movements and use them to their advantage for next time. Our Govt should not fall in to this trap. Releasing the video in public will help only enemies. It is a good decision. When we attack, it is an attack. No need to convince anybody. Don't release any video but do more surgical strikes so Pak will automatically gets proof. Our great army, kindly go ahead for more attacks like this and forget the old. Whearted support of Indians is with their great Army. Now this is the time that we all Indians be unite and not pressurize the PM and his Govt to release the video footage.
      1. D
        Doba Dodu
        Oct 10, 2016 at 1:46 pm
        You have forgotten China! India is scared of China! So, India and Indian media always downplay the India-china border dispute as China already thought an unforgettable lesson in 1962 war! Almost 125,000 sq km of Indian territory is either occupied or claimed by China! But, you still say, you have no issues with China! India's latest friend can do nothing in this regard. India is famous for interfering others internal affairs! It was an internal conflict with then East stan (Bangladesh) and Now stan! You got involved in their internal conflict to divide stan and occupied Bangladesh! You did the same thing in Sri Lanka by sending 90,000 strong Army there and you learned an unforgettable lesson there! India is a breeding ground of Hindu Tamil Tiger Terrorists and finally India learned an unforgettable lesson from LTTE. Aksai Chin is a disputed region located in the northwestern part of the Tibetan Plateau and immediately south of the western Kunlun Mountains. It is approximately 35,241 sq km in size is entirely administered by the People's Republic of China as a part of Hotan County in the Hotan Prefecture of Xinjiang Autonomous Region. India considers it as a part of its state of Jammu and Kashmir. The Trans-Karakoram Tract is an area of nearly 5,800 km2/ 5180 sq km (2,239 sq mi) along both sides of the Shaksgam River, is entirely administered by the People's Republic of China as a part of Kargilik County and Taxkorgan Tajik Autonomous County in the Kashgar Prefecture of Xinjiang Autonomous Region. It is still claimed by India as part of the state of Jammu and Kashmir. Arunachal Pradesh 83,743 sq km is a state of India, located in the far northeast. It borders the states of am and Nagaland to the south, and shares international borders with Burma in the east, Bhutan in the west, and the People's Republic of China in the north. The majority of the territory is claimed by the People's Republic of China as part of South Tibet.
        1. I
          Ishrat Sharma
          Oct 8, 2016 at 5:20 pm
          Keep on talking and don't produce a proof. Your politicians are making a fool out of you.
          1. D
            Oct 6, 2016 at 11:18 am
            INDIAN POLITICIANS USED TO FOOL INDIANS!lt;br/gt;NOW IT'S INDIAN ARMY'S TURN!!lt;br/gt;LET US LEARN HOW INDIAN ARMY DID A SURGICAL STRIKE IN SRI LANKA?lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;The unforgettable Surgical Strike of the Great Indian Army was, where 33 para troopers of the 10th Para Regiment were brutally killed by the LTTE during heli-landing to the ground of University of Jaffna on 11th October 1987! We still remember it Mr. Subramani! The heli-borne ault on the Jaffna University was one significant phase of the battle code named �Operation Pawan� on the night of 11 October 1987. Aim of this commando raid was to capture the top LTTE terrorist leadership and local commanders who were operating inside the University building at the time of the raid, according to Indian Intelligence. Thus thirty three para troopers including Lieutenant Colonel A.K. Chhabra fell victim to LTTE indiscriminate fire halfway their landing. "Firing at para troopers before their landing was a blatant violation of the Geneva Convention ped in 1949." India said ( is the Indian version of Geneva Convention which does not applies to Indian Occupied Kashmir).lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Let us see how The Great Indian 'Zeros' were respecting the same Geneva Convention: The Jaffna hospital macre occurred on October 21 and 22, 1987, during the Sri Lankan Civil War, when troops of the Indian Army entered the premises of the Jaffna Teaching Hospital in Jaffna, Sri Lanka, and killed between 60-70 patients and staf. The rebel Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, the government of Sri Lanka, and independent observers such as the University Teachers for Human Rights and others have called it a macre of civilians. Same thing is repeated by the Great Indian 'zeros' in Indian Occupied Kashmir today! lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;We also remember how the 90,000 strong Great Indian Army struggled with 4000 Hindu Tamil Tiger Terrorists and left Sri Lanka unsuccessfully with shame after loosing over 2000 Great Indian 'Zeros' in action and several thousand wounded! It was the mighty stani Airforce which finally helped Sri Lanka to defeat Terrorism forever!
            1. Load More Comments