Paternity leave will be just a holiday for men, says Maneka Gandhi

The legislation would mean that India would join the ranks of Eastern European and Nordic countries that have the longest fully paid maternity leave.

Written by Shalini Nair | New Delhi | Updated: August 25, 2016 10:50 am
labour ministry, maternity benefit, Maneka Gandhi, paternity benefit, Maneka Gandhi Paternity leave, ministry of women and child development, maternity benefit act, paternity, indian express WCD Minister Maneka Gandhi was the driving force behind the maternity Bill.

As the clamour for enhanced paternity leave grows stronger after the recent passage of the maternity leave bill in Rajya Sabha, Women and Child Development Minister Maneka Gandhi has said that such a legislation will have little impact in India, where men do not even avail their existing leave entitlements to share the responsibility of child care.

Speaking to The Indian Express, Maneka said, “Paternity leave can be considered only if, once the woman goes back to work after her 26 weeks of leave, we find that men are availing their sick leave for a month to take care of the child. Let me see how many men do that. I will be happy to give it but for a man, it will be just a holiday, he won’t do anything.”

It was on Maneka’s insistence that the Ministry of Labour and Employment mooted the Maternity Benefit (Amendment) Bill, 2016, which increases the period of leave for new mothers from the existing 12 weeks to 26 weeks in the organised sector. It also allows 12 weeks of leave to mothers going in for adoption or commissioning a child through surrogacy, and encourages employers to facilitate ‘work from home’ for new mothers.

The legislation would mean that India would join the ranks of Eastern European and Nordic countries that have the longest fully paid maternity leave. However, it would be left out of the league of 78 countries which, according to the International Labour Organisation, offer decent paid paternity leave. The demand for mandatory paternity leave has come from several women MPs as well as civil society members, who contend that merely increasing the leave for mothers could be counterproductive as it will reinforce the gender norm of women being the sole in-charge of child care and domestic work.

Watch VideoGovt Moves To Ban Commercial Surrogacy: What It Means


“If men gave me one iota of hope by taking sick leave for child care, then yes, we can think of mooting a proposal for paternity leave,” Maneka said.

According to a notification issued in the late ’90s under the Central Civil Services Leave Rules, men in government service — biological as well as adoptive fathers — can take 15 days of paid leave, which they are allowed to merge with any other leave. There is no legislation mandating compulsory leave for fathers in the private sector, with many companies granting paternity leave for a week or two at the most.

It is also argued that only increasing maternity leave will further bias employers against hiring women. A recent study released by the National Commission for Women (NCW) showed prevalence of widespread discrimination against pregnant women in the corporate sector in India. Both the NCW study as well as a 2011 report by the Labour Ministry state that decent maternity leave by itself leads to mounting the pressure on women’s productive and reproductive roles and, hence, longer paternity leave is an idea whose time has come in India.

Dismissing reports that the Union government will take the ordinance route to bring the Bill into immediate effect, Maneka said that the Maternity Benefit Bill will have to wait to be passed in Lok Sabha until the winter session of Parliament.

The WCD Ministry, meanwhile, is planning on introducing “safeguards to prevent any misuse of the maternity bill”. These include making it mandatory for women to work for a stipulated amount of time before they can avail the enhanced leave. “It could be one year; we might let the companies decide on what this minimum period should be,” said ministry sources.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. A
    Amanda Jones
    Feb 14, 2017 at 9:43 am
    Good day Everyone reading this true life story of my life. My name is Amanda Jones,i am from south Africa, a single mother with 2 kids. i have been involve in so many scammers on the internet taking my hard earn money, looking for a consolidation loan, until one faithful night, i pra and i believe God directed me to this loan company on the internet by name ()they isted me with 250 000 00 after good 8 months contacting so many fake lenders on net, please my people, be very careful obtaining loan with upfront fee without no guarantee or confirmation that the firm is legit. this loan company came to my rescue when i needed them most, at first i never trust them, but after meeting up to their demand, i was a happy woman. which is the most important thing in life. today i consolidate my debt and i am also proud of my own flat. my mother and two friends benefited from this offer, and i also want the entire country to benefit from this generous offer. you can contact them via email () and you will be happy as am today
    1. A
      Abhinav Gour
      Aug 24, 2016 at 2:58 am
      She is One Woman who maybe has been Abused v v Badly by any of her Families Men Folk and thats the reason She is so much against each and every Indian Men and their Rights
      1. A
        Anil Bg
        Aug 24, 2016 at 5:01 pm
        The comment is so wrong and she being a women and minister has made a comment not suiting her stature and age
        1. A
          Aug 24, 2016 at 6:11 pm
          Its concerning that a minister of her stature is so biased which will only hinder the origins of gender neutral laws that we are slowly by finally heading towards. Me being in IT I have seen so many parents men and women who take turns to take care of their kids. Evil/Bad has no gender/caste/age/creed.
          1. A
            Aug 24, 2016 at 5:47 pm
            Highly disagree with your view.. All r not same.. A lady needs her husband to deal with her mood swings, to motivate her, to support her, n I'm pretty sure husband is only that person who can understand her in every manner.. Her mother father can not be everywhere so it is only her husband who can give her mental peace.. Yes you are right he will enjoy but with his partner.. So kindly think before delivering such statements Ma'am..
            1. D
              Aug 24, 2016 at 12:19 pm
              Cheap pority to remain in news. Certainly ignorant about Indian social fabric. Better care for dogs and cats, humans are different.
              1. I
                Intolerant Sickular
                Aug 30, 2016 at 8:04 am
                More achche din by the BJP Govt. Yay
                1. R
                  Aug 24, 2016 at 1:41 pm
                  Such a sad opiniated womn you have become... You used to be a woman to admire... But sadly you have become a feminist... Coming to your opinion there are many women who just give birth Nd avail all leaves but hardly take care of their child... What happens then... You have no way of seeing to that... So basically you yourself have become double standard... Very sad
                  1. R
                    Aug 24, 2016 at 1:50 pm
                    M sorry madam we Indian men are not that dumb too..
                    1. R
                      Aug 25, 2016 at 3:02 am
                      Dear Madam,lt;br/gt;I respect your statement but please don't impose generic mentality of dehati people.. Now things changed, most of the man take much care better than wives.. It's was long back when man were not giving time coz families were United.. He had thought lot of people from family are there to take care of child and mother.. But now nuclear families has different mind set. Plz don't drag us back to old mentality.. We always wish to stay with family u just make sure that we will get leave from employer.. Taking leave won't affect. You are working for gov. It's easy for u to say about sick leave.. Let's it with private employer..
                      1. A
                        Aug 28, 2016 at 5:57 am
                        Hi , with due respect to all men and specially the ones who think they do enough to support their partner and deserve a good paternity off . Cheers hope that happens , who doesn't like free holiday!! . I personally feel that it's women who go through the big change in her life , physically , emotionally and ofcourse she not only have to manage that but also her new born. Men usually can help in buying veg to home and taking care of main things like changing nappies when they are asked to.they can't breast feed , they are not the actually going through the change. If asked to be considerate they give a lecture on 100 women who have given birth.i know a fren who actually went on vacation , when his wife is taking care of new born along with their mom/mom in law. So personally I agree with each and every Menaka hi'a statement.if u look at the comments posted by men in this article itself, you will realise that Indian men are still not mature enough to actually take care of new born and wife . They still are the breadwinner in their head and just doing a little bit they actually think they need paternity off for it . personally I would prefer having enough money to hire a good caring helper , who actually does help , who can cook and give food ( in case m not feeling well). If the husband is given off , I guess women will end up taking care of them also along with their child ( which is a bigger torture) . So please guys give women some space to heal and u really want to help why not after office or on sat /sun . So m totally in favour of 26 weeks maternity leave , paternity leave might even end up disturbing the mother than of help.
                        1. R
                          Raman Vijay
                          Apr 23, 2017 at 12:14 pm
                          So you are also one men hater feminist who thinks men are not human and should not be given any kind of benefits .. why not you just die ? Every statement of yours is based on your disgusting"guess".. In reality its women who enjoy and don't take care of childs.. They just don't
                        2. Y
                          Aug 25, 2016 at 4:35 am
                          I can give her two iotas of hope , give her my contact . her comments are brash and away from ground reality . if men do not prefer to take sick leave for child it's because so that he can ensure bread on plate of sick child and his mother every day in extra compeive Indian environment ...
                          1. K
                            Aug 25, 2016 at 12:50 am
                            One persons opinion does not matter. was it even worth my time reading such an article ? News has dropped an all time low.
                            1. A
                              Akshay S
                              Aug 24, 2016 at 8:22 am
                              True. People skip voting days;br/gt;It will be another holiday and most of them would be sleeping or having fun with their friends while their pregnant wife is at home. lt;br/gt;They leave her with the family(mostly mother) and;br/gt;Though I believe some leaves just before and after birth of the child has to be given.
                              1. A
                                Anil Kalaga
                                Aug 24, 2016 at 3:33 am
                                Maneka hi was probably talking about her own experience and probably her husband was busy what he has become so famous for when Varun hi was born!
                                1. A
                                  Anupam Dubey
                                  Aug 24, 2016 at 5:01 am
                                  Is this the view that Narendra Modi Government has about Father's? Is this what the country thinks about Father's? Looks like Ministry of Women and Child Development needs a Fatherless society. She must be removed from ministership for making such abusive statement against Fathers of India.
                                  1. A
                                    Aug 24, 2016 at 8:44 am
                                    She is losing one vote of mine for such comment..
                                    1. A
                                      Aug 25, 2016 at 12:45 pm
                                      How can a women and child development minister decide the fate of men? We need a National Commission and a Ministry for men.
                                      1. P
                                        PN badri
                                        Aug 26, 2016 at 8:26 am
                                        Matha,pitha,guru deivam is philosophy of India and ignoring father's role is not correct.
                                        1. B
                                          Bob Bhatt
                                          Aug 24, 2016 at 4:54 am
                                          Men want paternity leave, show the picture to Boss that you are cleaning utensils and rooms in the house.
                                          1. M
                                            Mohammad Bin Tughlaq
                                            Aug 24, 2016 at 6:16 am
                                            Thank you IE. Even if no one else will read what I wrote, the moderator at least may read it. Incidentally I am not aware what crime I did or what Lakshman Rekha of journalism I crossed?
                                            1. Load More Comments