Kerala: Archbishop’s memoirs could leave Congress, Left red-faced

Archbishop Emeritus Joseph Powathil’s memoirs, which appeared in Kudumbajyothi, monthly magazine of the Catholic Archdiocese of Changanassery could leave the Left and the Congress in displeasure.

Written by Liz Mathew | New Delhi | Published: November 2, 2015 1:55 am

Amid the campaigning for local body polls in Kerala, contents of a retired archbishop’s memoirs could embarrass both the ruling UDF and Opposition LDF.

Archbishop Emeritus Joseph Powathil’s memoirs, which appeared in Kudumbajyothi, monthly magazine of the Catholic Archdiocese of Changanassery, say T V Thomas, a former CPI minister, had expressed his desire to receive sacraments (penance and holy communion significant for Christians, particularly Catholics).

This could leave Kerala Communists red-faced, as they believe religion has no place in their movement. The article could also revive memories of a church statement that CPM MLA Mathai Chacko, who died in 2006, had been given the last sacrament by a priest on his deathbed. The statement had triggered furious remarks against bishops by then party secretary Pinarayi Vijayan.

Share This Article
Related Article

Powathil’s article in the magazine’s November issue could put Congress leaders in an awkward position, too. It refers to an agitation by private college managements in 1972, when the Congress’s youth and student wings took a stand against minority-run educational institutions. Then Kerala Students Union (KSU) leaders, including A K Antony and current PCC president V M Sudheeran, had reportedly even sought a review of a constitutional provision giving special protection to minority-run education institutions.

“The student wings protested against church-run institutions in Thrissur, Trivandrum and Changanassery,” Powathil, then auxiliary bishop of Changanassery, said. “I remember (current state culture minister) K C Joseph shouting slogans before the bishop’s house.”

Congress MP and former Union minister Vayalar Ravi, however, said the KSU had taken up the issue to build a progressive image for the party. “However, realising that it had alienated Christians, who have always backed Congress, Indiraji intervened.”

Antony said he did not regret his stand. “The protest was not against minorities, but against exploitation of education institute managements and for the rights of teachers and students.”

In the 1970s, the tussle between the Church and Congress led to a stalemate, with private education institutions run by Christian managements shutting down for months. On May 9, 1972, KSU leader M M Hassan brought a resolution in Kerala University Senate meet asking the Centre to give the state control of minority-run institutions. Later, a Youth Congress meeting in Malappuram demanded that education institutes be nationalised.

The then Congress-CPI coalition government decided to bring the fees in private colleges on a par with that of government colleges, and refused to provide aid to minority-run institutions. In protest, church-run colleges went on strike. Finally, CM Achuta Menon rolled out a compromise formula by which government would pay salaries of teachers in minority-run institutes if they agreed to certain conditions in appointments and admissions.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. H
    Nov 2, 2015 at 9:33 am
    As long as Articles 25-30 remain in the Consution, there will be NO INDIAN. Period.
    1. L
      Nov 2, 2015 at 9:37 am
      Typical of commies especially christians and muslims, they are closet believers.
      1. G
        Nov 2, 2015 at 7:30 am
        The Syrian Church in Kerala has always stood for the rich and the powerful. It has a deep dislike for the communists. Why Christianity and communism cannot go together? In South America this is the regular format. In Kerala, the clergy is feudal; they support the rich; their main preoccupation is fund raising. Can the poor raise funds? The Church should introspect before blaming the socialists? Was Jesus Christ a capitalist?
        1. T
          Thrinethran T
          Nov 2, 2015 at 6:20 am
          In his heart, A K Antony is for fairness and justice for all, and against the current horrendously biased regime that has long promoted mercenary minoritarianism. But did he ever stand a chance to practise his convictions?
          1. I
            Nov 2, 2015 at 8:25 am
            The behaviour of MINO-RITIES in Kerala are indicative of what will happen to India if ever Mino-rities get enough MPs to manite the elected Govt through VOTE BANKING. Calling Chris-stians who are 24% of Kerala potion and Mu-slims who are 26% of Kerala potion "MINO-RITY" is a JOKE and indicate that the Mu-slims and Chris-tians will demand min-ority special rights till they become more than 50% of the potion in Kerala/ India. When MINO-RITIES become 50% of Indian potion secularism in India will END as has happened in Kerala. In Kerala Mus-lims vote for only Mu-slim League and where Mus-lim League candidates are not contesting they vote for Congress. Similarly Chri-stians vote for only Church Supported Political parties - Kerala Congresses (there are more than one of them) and for Congress where Church Supported parties are not contesting. ........................ The COMMUNAL DIVIDE led by MINO-RITIES in Kerala is ABSOLUTE with the COMMUNIST PARTIES being the HI-NDU PARTY in Kerala.
            1. Load More Comments