For the Left in Bengal, religion is no longer the opium of the masses

The CPI(M) never fully gave up religion during its 34-year-old rule, which means that the rediscovery of both spirituality and rituals isn’t totally unfamiliar – or apolitical.

Written by Esha Roy | Published:June 30, 2017 6:24 pm
  Communism in West Bengal, left wing in Bengal, communism, communism-religion, CPM, opium of masses, religion in west bengal, indian express Flag of CPI(M)

Deserted streets greeted the heavy monsoon rains that lashed Kolkata last weekend, as the city celebrated two religious festivals – Rath Yatra on Sunday, a major Hindu festival in both Bengal and Orissa, and along with the sighting of the new moon, Eid on Monday. While there is absolutely nothing unusual about either event, the festivals or the rains at this time of the year in West Bengal, there was an unexpected development in store. Greetings and wishes for both the Rath Yatra as well Eid from Left leaders in the West Bengal capital.

While this may seem to be a matter of course, fact is this was probably one of the first festivals for which CPI(M) West Bengal Surya Kanta Mishra sent greetings out on Whatsapp. How the threat of being left out in the hearts and minds of people makes Left leaders change.

CPI(M) MLA from Dun Dum Uttar (in North 24 Paraganas district) Tanmay Bhattacharya went to the extent of actually attending a ‘Rath yatra’ as well as Iftar parties in his district. The MLA, one of the few left in the West Bengal assembly, has since been slammed by other sections of the Left parties – the more radical CPI(ML) for instance – for selling its principles in a desperate bid to regain electoral popularity.

The CPI(ML) has also accused it of not only being no longer Communist, but what is worse, of being not very different from non-Communist parties such as the Trinamool Congress and the Indian National Congress.

While Marxism itself rests on the premise of atheism and that religion is the opium of the masses, fact is tmany CPI(M) leaders in the past have lent support to Bengal’s two biggest religious festivals – Durga Puja and Kali puja – but discretely, from behind the scenes. The pujas are held in every ‘para’, or colony, in Kolkata city and in the districts, and local clubs (youth or sports clubs) run mostly by young men have traditionally organized them.

These clubs are a ready-made pool of people to be turned and influenced by the political party of the time – for 34 years the CPI(M) and for the last six, the Trinamool Congress. But while the Trinamool has been unabashed and unapologetic about its support to these pujas, with chief minister Mamata Banerjee herself inaugurating dozens of Pujas across the city and her cabinet ministers following suit and even holding their own pujas — former transport minister and Sarada-accused Madan Mitra, Urban Development Minister Firhad Hakim and minister for North Bengal Development Aroop Biswas have three of the most popular and ostentatious Durga pujas in the city — the CPI(M) has had reason to be a lot more careful to not appear “religious” or endorse any religion.

There are stories that are told even to this day about former CPI(M) Transport Minister Subhash Chakraborty being “caught” offering prayers at a neighbourhood Kali temple. Or about former chief minister Jyoti Basu’s wife visiting Tarakeshwar temple often enough.

But visibly, the CPI(M) has always given a wide berth to religious rites and rituals. The extent of it’s involvement in any puja would be the setting up of makeshift stalls in front of or adjacent to puja pandals from which they would sell Marxist literature and biographies of eminent communist leaders from around the world.

The Communists still set up stalls, but these stalls are no longer popular.

In their time, Left leaders much preferred book fairs to connect with the intelligentsia.The CPI(M) began numerous book fairs, in the capital and across the state. The book fairs were secular. Nobody could object to promoting the habit of reading. Soon they became the venues for the rulers to openly mingle and connect with the ruled.

Educational outreach performed more than one goal. The Bangiya Shakharata Prasar Samiti (Bengal education expansion organisations) across the state imparted vocational and other training to youth and organized various camps, including blood donation. These social activities allowed the Left parties to keep in constant touch with the electorate. The BSPS still exists, but only on paper, and these activities are no longer carried out.

The CPI(M) and other Left parties are now left with few or no avenues to reconnect with West Bengal’s population. Religious festivals have therefore become a choice venue. What seems to have spurred the party’s return to religion is its belief that their exit from power has left a vacuum which hasn’t been fully filled by the Trinamool.

Moreover, not wanting to be associated with religious festivals was what gave the Trinamool leaders a foothold to enter the public gaze in the first place. Even when Left leaders would assist pujas behind the scenes, it was the Trinamool leaders who would inaugurate these pujas and participate in and attend its rituals.

The rise of the RSS and the BJP in Bengal, while still nascent, means that this vacuum is once again up for grabs; not surprisingly, Left leaders say the BJP is far more dangerous rival than the TMC. They point out that in Dum Dum Uttar, it was the RSS attempt to take over and “control and patronize” the constituency’s Rath Yatra which propelled former chief minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya to push past the Left’s distaste of religious ceremonies and to assert his presence.

Whatever the reason may be, in a state where the ultimate paradox has been the co-habitation of religion and Communism, both equally important aspects of daily life in Bengal, the softening of the CPI(M)’s stance on religious festivals is not only timely but also shows the party’s ability to not be hemmed in by its once-inflexible rule book.

The journey is long and the destination is far, but if the Left is able to keep alive its ability to transform itself, in keeping with the changing circumstances and the needs of the hour, it may just surprise itself – and the people of West Bengal.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. S
    Sudipto Bannerjee
    Jul 11, 2017 at 7:47 am
    For better or for worse, Bengal was a good place, till the RSS came in. Wonder when we will reclaim our precious land!
    Reply
    1. M
      mas
      Jul 11, 2017 at 4:23 am
      There is not a doubt that Commies destroyed Bengala (for that matter Kerala also). Hindus have been killed by Muslims and there is no voice from Commies against the violence by Muslims. They are scared of BJP and RSS because they know that Hindus may support RSS and BJP. If that happens it would be good for Bengal. Commies never supported Hindus and Hindu festival, except Hindu money and women.But they arrange Durga pujapandals to get money donated by the devotees. I had a classmate, who was student member of SFI. One month beffore the puja festival he takes off from his research andmf833 help in building pandals. He told me that he collects around 200K rupees every day during puja.
      Reply
      1. L
        lenin
        Jul 10, 2017 at 12:24 pm
        Karl Marks and Stalin will be laughing in their graves about the plight of the lazy Indian commies.
        Reply
        1. R
          RAKESH KUMAR
          Jul 10, 2017 at 11:34 am
          Let the leftists admit that all these yrs. they were not only fooling masses of India but adopting double standard. It also shows how communists were cruel enough to not to allow wife of their CM (Jyoti Basu) a non-political citizen and depriving her from following her religious belief. They same communists are crying from roof top alleging Modi govt. to deprive minorities (read muslims christians) from their religious beliefs. I do remember news appearing in print media when the them Minister of left govt. Subhash Chakrabory was caught on camera while offering his prayer in a pooja pandal in Kolkata. This shows the terror of left party on one of their powerful minister. Left means terror which can be equated with islam and like religious beliefs.
          Reply
          1. M
            Ml Pandit
            Jul 8, 2017 at 11:17 am
            Only Hindu religion is opium to masses for Indian communists from day one?
            Reply
            1. S
              Shailendra Nagar
              Jul 7, 2017 at 5:39 pm
              The Leftists who do not believe in religion but has no hesitation in using religion for their political gains. In fact. the present Indian communists have no ideology to follow. Their only job is to add fuel to fire. They relish on the votes of some politically corrupt people of this country.
              Reply
              1. K
                Kannan
                Jul 7, 2017 at 6:30 am
                both cpm and clients are anti India and pro china is currently evident from their silence in summit stand off. These Chinese stooges led by Pinarayi tweets against Isreal when our PM was there. what they have done to Bengal or kerala?. No industrial development for many years. kerala is a debt ridden state. other than tweeting Pinarayi can do nothing. they have to depend on TN or Kanataka for their vegetable requirements. despite good rain fall adequate water, they do nothing and talk of farmers etc. they are completely wiped off except in kerala. tripura is tottering. WB is lost. irrelevant fellows in current situation context of the changing world. even for the own RS seat, neither yechury nor D Raja can stand on their own leg.
                Reply
                1. N
                  Nambrath Krishna
                  Jul 6, 2017 at 8:23 pm
                  Bengal left imitating brethren aping mindset in Kerala. In Kerala CPM had attempted to hijack Hindu religious festivals celebrated by the other extreme of their political thought. Though BJP a non-en y in Kerala but it's parental organisation RSS and it's siblings have wide reach in Kerala's socio-cultural arena that sent jitters into CPM and hence the vain attempt on the part of Leftist. And on Kerala comrades' advise Bengal comrades on blind pursuit.
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments