ED notice to Karti for alleged FEMA violation, Chidambaram says govt can’t silence my voice

The ED alleged that the FEMA violations were made while infusing foreign investment in the eye care chain through venture capital firms such as Sequoia Capital and Westbridge Capital.

Written by Deeptiman Tiwary | New Delhi | Updated: April 18, 2017 6:53 am
p chidambaram, karti chidambaram, ed, enforcement directorate, forex violation, Vasan Health Care,money laundering, india news, indian express P Chidambaram’s son, Karti Chidambaram.

The Enforcement Directorate Monday said it had issued show-cause notice to Karti Chidambaram and a firm purportedly linked to him for alleged violation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) to the tune of Rs 45 crore. The agency issued a similar notice to Chennai-based M/s Vasan Health Care Private Limited for alleged FEMA violation of more than Rs 2,100 crore.

The ED said it was also probing Karti’s father P Chidambaram, senior Congress leader and former Union Minister, for granting FIPB approval in the Aircel-Maxis case.

In a statement, Chidambaram said: “The Enforcement Directorate has the habit of recycling allegations from time to time. Today’s press release by the ED is another example. The allegations in the press release are baseless, totally false and ridiculous.”

“No notice has been served upon Karti Chidambaram so far. If a notice is received, a suitable reply will be sent. By targeting Karti Chidambaram with baseless notices, the government cannot silence my voice or stop my writing,” Chidambaram said.

Karti Chidambaram was quoted by NDTV as saying “the more my father speaks up, the more I am targeted”. He also took to Twitter: “Oh wow! If I am served a “notice”, it’s a Big if, for supposed FEMA violations of a co in which I was never a shareholder or director, Ummmm.”

The ED alleged that the FEMA violations were made while infusing foreign investment in the Vasan eye care chain through venture capital firms such as Sequoia Capital and Westbridge Capital. The ED called into question investments made by these companies into Vasan on the ground that shares were not bought directly from the company but through its promoter A M Arun.

READ| Cannot silence my voice by targetting my son: P Chidambaram on ED show-cause notice

“Show cause notice has been issued to M/s Vasan Health Care Private Limited, its promoter director Shri Arun, Smt Arun, Shri Dwarakanathan and also to the overseas investors for the alleged contraventions… Show cause notice has been issued to M/s Advantage Strategic Consulting Pvt Ltd, its directors and also to Shri Karti P Chidambaram who appears to be the controller and ultimate beneficiary in these transactions,” an ED statement said.

In January, Karti Chidambaram, in an email response to a query from The Indian Express, had said: “Sequoia and Westbridge are to my knowledge well acclaimed global PE/VC funds. I have had no business transactions with either of them. The ED is on a fishing and roving exercise to harass and defame me. All this is an unfortunate fallout of this toxic game.”

The ED said it was also probing P Chidambaram for granting FIPB (Foreign Investment Promotion Board)approval in the Aircel-Maxis case. “Further investigations under PMLA are going on in respect of FIPB approval given to Aircel-Maxis by the then Finance Minister wherein foreign inflow was Rs 3,500 crore (appx.) whereas as per government policy and FIPB guidelines, competent authority was CCEA (Cabinet Committee of Economic Affairs) for any inflow above Rs 600 crore,” the ED said.

In a statement earlier this month, Chidambaram said he had granted approval to the Aircel-Maxis deal “in the normal course of business”.

“In the Aircel-Maxis case, taking into account the face value of the foreign investment, the FIPB submitted the case to the Finance Minister and sought approval. As FM, I granted approval in the normal course of business,” he said.

The ED said it conducted investigations into foreign investments received by Vasan Health Care Pvt Limited on the basis of inputs received by them about suspected contraventions under FEMA.

“Preliminary investigation revealed that the said company had received investments from the funds of Sequoia and WestBridge, based at Mauritius, and also through investment arms of M/s GIC, Singapore,” the ED statement said.

According to the ED notice, overseas investors acquired shares of Vasan Healthcare by acquiring Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares (CCPS) directly from the company by investing a total amount of Rs 432 crore in different rounds of investment from February 2009 to November 2014. The shares were acquired by the overseas investors at the face value of Rs 100 each, the ED stated.

“In addition, the overseas investors, instead of acquiring equity shares from the company directly, which would have added more liquidity to the company, chose to acquire the same in the secondary market viz., from the existing shareholders of the company including its promoter Shri A M Arun, M/s AMA Associates (a partnership firm belonging to the promoter Shri A M Arun and his father-in-law Shri Dwarakanathan) and M/s Advantage Strategic Consulting P Limited, a company whose activities are found to be in the control of Shri Karti P Chidambaram,” the ED said.

According to ED, the first tranche of sale took place in the end of 2010 when shares were sold at Rs 7,500 per share. The second tranche of sale took place in March and May 2012 when shares were sold at Rs 5,242 per share. The total amount invested by the overseas investors, which ultimately benefited the above mentioned existing share holders, is Rs 357.72 crore, the ED said.

One of the overseas investors of the Sequoia group who invested in the CCPS of Vasan in the first round of investment in February 2009, sold stake worth around Rs 25 crore in March 2012, to one of the investment arms of GIC Singapore for Rs 177.40 crore, getting a return of more than seven times of their investment, the ED said.

“Mrs Arun, promoter of M/s Vasan who was allotted equity shares of face value of Rs 100 each on payment of premium of Rs 100, transferred 300,000 equity shares to her father Shri Dwarakanathan without receiving any consideration. Shri Arun immediately organised the transfer of 150,000 shares from Dwarakanathan to M/s Advantage Strategic Consulting P Limited, who were never connected to the activities of the company till that date. Although the shares had a total face value of Rs 1.50 crore and was acquired by the original allottee for Rs 3 crore, which included a premium of Rs 1.50 crore, M/s Advantage Strategic Consulting P Limited, paid to transferor Shri Dwarakanathan Rs 50 lakh only, and that too after a period of more than one year from the date of transfer of shares,” the ED statement said.

According to ED, Dr Arun, while negotiating with the overseas investors in selling his stake, facilitated and ensured that shares held by Advantage are also sold. Of the 150,000 shares, Advantage sold 30,000 shares to one of the investors from the Sequoia group and received consideration of around Rs 22.50 crore, the ED said.

“It was only after the receipt of the consideration, they transferred the remaining amount of Rs 1 crore to Dwarakanathan,” the ED statement said.

“During the investigation it was revealed that various agreements were entered from time to time between the company, promoters, investors, seller of shares etc. The CCPS were issued to the overseas investors wherein the price/conversion formula have not been determined upfront at the time of issuance of the shares. Further, as per the agreements, the overseas investors were given assurance of returns in one form or other. Such assurance of returns and non-determination of the price/conversion formula upfront are not permitted and are in contravention of FEMA,” the ED statement said.

The ED alleged that Vasan had not followed statutory obligations as envisaged under FEMA, 1999 in their reporting mechanism to Reserve Bank and failure on their part also resulted in contravention of FEMA.

“The total amount of contravention identified to have been committed by M/s Vasan Health Care Private Limited and its overseas investors on different counts in the investments received from overseas investors is around Rs 2,100 crore,” the ED statement said.

 

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: April 18, 2017 4:25 am
  1. S
    SC
    Apr 18, 2017 at 4:21 pm
    What voice ? When Mr. P Chidambaram was Home Minister he ordered lathicharging of sleeping children and sleeping women at midnight in RamLila Maidan. Then he said that law will take its course. Now ED has taken some action. Wait. Where is the question of silencing your voice.
    Reply
    1. V
      vasudevan
      Apr 18, 2017 at 2:19 pm
      Congress itself has lost all its voice. How does PC think that he has got a voice which anyone bothers to listen, leave alone the Govt
      Reply
      1. S
        Shankar
        Apr 18, 2017 at 1:42 pm
        Isnt that kiddish comment from PC, what is there to stop PC form talking, entire nation knows PC & his family hv been corrupt, why U hv to make silly comments, instead surrender and confesss maybe Apex court will show some mercy by giving U life improsnment, well thats what i am wishing for.
        Reply
        1. R
          rishi
          Apr 18, 2017 at 1:08 pm
          PC Visibly Sheepish And Silly.....playing the victim-card will not do ! Cheats, pseudos, pretentious and wilfully insensitive people to the core.....chidambaram is part of the greed-driven gang where everyone from the peon to the president ended up doing "jee hujoori" to an italian housewife in a "(corruption) chalta hai" culture generated, perpetrated and practised by them for which they were disgracefully ousted by crores of aspiring young women and men in search of clean and honest livelihoods in an environment of National Pride. Corruption cannot be condoned.....RSS-BJP-Combine-Led-NDA must bring each and everyone congressi and their kin to book . The Nation was looted for 65years by some anti-Indians in our society whose greed for money and power kept this Nation 65years behind the rest of the world as economically, industrially, and agriculturally it moved at a snail's pace during those crooked regimes while most other countries leaped forward in the same duration
          Reply
          1. S
            Shankar
            Apr 18, 2017 at 1:45 pm
            Well said, it seems Karti Chidambaram charged $15k for getting appointment of his dad & MMS(PM), i have met that Karti in person, to call him dumb will be insulting to Donkey!!!
            Reply
          2. R
            Ramji Ram
            Apr 18, 2017 at 11:39 am
            ASTROLOGER` ALL` PROBLEM` SOLUTION LOVE MARRIAGE SPECIALIST BABA JI 91-7073636169 ज्योतिष से पूछें सवाल, पाइये समस्याओं के समाधान भारत विश्व प्रसिद्ध ज्योतिषी मोबाइल फोन 91-7073636169 समस्याओं कैसे दूर, होगी पति-पत्नी के बीच अनबन को दूर करने के उपाय प्रेम विवाह की समस्या समाधान विश्व प्रसिद्ध ज्योतिषी ब्रिटेन usa- ऑस्ट्रेलिया दुबई जापान कनाडा इटली ेशिया संतोषजनक समाधान {{ 91-7073636169}} सभी प्रकार की समस्या समाधान - vashikaran specialist- blak जादू Intercast शादी विशेषज्ञ बाबा जी सिर्फ एक कॉल कीजिये 91-7073636169
            Reply
            1. A
              Ashwin
              Apr 18, 2017 at 11:33 am
              Mr. Chidambarm's statement implies a lot. What it means is that Governments do all investigations to silence the opposition parties. Do we then understand that ,during his tenure as FM, all the notices, raids, investigations were carried out to silence the opposite persons ? PC sir do you remember your IT dept sent notice to Shri Amitabh Bachhan when he was under hospitalization ? So accept the investigation gracefully and fight it in legal forum. In any case, we donot believe you or any of your Congress fellows.
              Reply
              1. S
                Shankar
                Apr 18, 2017 at 1:48 pm
                absolutely and the CBI raids on DMK family, Mayawati etc etc, its nothing but PC is scared now, like Kanimozhi PC`s son Karti will be in Tihar soon., i will definitely wish that happens soon.
                Reply
              2. K
                KRavindra Ballal
                Apr 18, 2017 at 10:06 am
                Chidambaram is the very personification of all that is evil in congress and is hated by the common man.Arrogant opportunistic psedo Aristocrat he is trieng to give a political colour to the ED action against his son hoping that it will divert the attention of the people.However the citizens of this country have matured politically and will see through his motives.Hope both he and his son get the just deserts.
                Reply
                1. R
                  Ravishankar
                  Apr 18, 2017 at 9:41 am
                  Father, son combination working very hard to somehow fool the people!
                  Reply
                  1. M
                    Mahender Goriganti
                    Apr 18, 2017 at 9:18 am
                    Why should anybody believe that chibbi's thinks voice any value or anybody cares for it other than Islamic Express ??
                    Reply
                    1. I
                      imti
                      Apr 18, 2017 at 8:30 am
                      govt justs wants to go after teh illegal monies and not you or your family as yu have streamlined illegal payments to many at top of yuor chain, Chidu
                      Reply
                      1. P
                        P Chandrasekr
                        Apr 18, 2017 at 8:29 am
                        Mr. Chidambaram is crying wolf over this. In fact, this should have happened long ago. By the way, why should the govt. be worried about Mr. Chidambaram. He has been having a jolly free ride on the media and giving his 2 paise worth on all and sundry. it is just that he is scared and is reacting like every other politician in this manner. Mr. Chidambaram, please use all your skills and defend yourself and your son rather than casting aspersion on this govt.
                        Reply
                        1. I
                          indian
                          Apr 18, 2017 at 7:58 am
                          Karti charged foreign companies 15 crores to set up appointments with MMS. Crook.
                          Reply
                          1. I
                            Ivan
                            Apr 18, 2017 at 7:06 am
                            With the lousy experience that foreign multinationals had with India, it is only natural that foreigners especially foreigners of Indian origin (hint Maxis), who know the Indian way of backstabbing foreign partners, seek some form of insurance by courting influence. India is not some kind of goldmine for foreigners. By and large everyone who had ever invested money in capital development India has lost it. The FDI seen nowadays is largely in gilt edged bonds and the remaining in blue chip local companies. Nobody with any sense will invest in fixed capital in India without political backing, if at all.
                            Reply
                            1. D
                              David
                              Apr 18, 2017 at 7:59 am
                              You sound sed off. Why are you supporting the corrupt. India is a nation. Beyond investments. Is rule based. And rules apply equally. Chindu, wife and son Karti are drowning in ill gotten wealth of poor Indians.
                              Reply
                              1. I
                                Ivan
                                Apr 18, 2017 at 10:16 am
                                There are no 'poor' Indians in the business world. Only those who have connections and those who temporarily have not.
                              2. D
                                David
                                Apr 18, 2017 at 10:41 am
                                When income is forged, unaccounted and taxes not paid. The poor are affected seriously. Then Chidambaram was elected to serve the people not his family and pocket millions through under hand dealings.
                                Reply
                              3. M
                                Murthy
                                Apr 18, 2017 at 6:23 am
                                New Indian Express had provided details of foreign accounts held by Karthi, with the account numbers, and of a house in the London area, owned jointly by PC, Karthi and Karthi's wife. No rebuttal from PC or denial of any sort that I have come across. If there had been, I hope, someone will point it out to me.... thanks...
                                Reply
                                1. M
                                  Murthy
                                  Apr 18, 2017 at 6:16 am
                                  Last year, Auditor Gurumurthy, had published a detailed account in the New Indian Express, of how these dubious transactions were conducted using the "Mauritius route" and "Vasan Eye Care" [ "eye wash" !!!]. At that time, PC had not bothered to provide a proper rebuttal of the specific facts mentioned in Gurumurthy's article. Therefore, It is entirely proper that the ED is taking this action...
                                  Reply
                                  1. M
                                    mukesh gandhi
                                    Apr 18, 2017 at 1:47 am
                                    intha chetti payalum, evanoda appanum, periya thiruttu payaluva sonia , avaloda mavan senja kutrathai vida evanga periya thirudargal
                                    Reply
                                    1. K
                                      Kshetij Thakker
                                      Apr 18, 2017 at 12:18 am
                                      Camel aaya pahad kay nichay aur Chiddu aaya Modi kay nichay
                                      Reply
                                      1. Load More Comments