Crackdown on NGOs: PM Modi may face tough questions from US

In March this year, Royce and more than 100 members of the US Congress had written to Home Minister Rajnath Singh, asking him to allow US-based charity Compassion International to continue its work in India.

Written by Shubhajit Roy | Washington Dc | Updated: June 26, 2017 2:15 pm
 pm modi, narendra modi, modi-trump, ngo crackdown, christian charity organisation, Foreign Contributions Regulations Act, india news, indian express Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressing Indian diaspora in Washington (PTI)

Three months after Christian charity organisation Compassion International was forced to shut its operations in India following a government directive, the Indian side may be asked some tough questions from US interlocutors on the crackdown on NGOs during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s stay here.

The Prime Minister, who arrived in Washington DC Saturday night, will meet US administration officials Sunday onward and US President Donald Trump Monday.

Influential US Congressman and chairman of the House Foreign Affairs committee, Ed Royce, told The Indian Express, “The US-India partnership is critically important, and that’s why I hope Prime Minister Modi will take time to listen to those who are concerned about crackdowns on non-governmental organisations, including the shuttering of Compassion International that was providing critical tutoring, nutrition and medical services to more than 145,000 Indian children.”

Royce has been at the forefront of those critical of the Indian government’s actions against NGOs, especially Compassion International.

Since the current US administration has a strong base in the conservative constituency in the US, Modi’s visit may give an opportunity for the administration to raise this issue. While it is highly unlikely that Trump may raise the issue, other key administration officials may raise this with the Prime Minister and his official delegation, US officials indicated.

David Curry, president and CEO of Open Doors USA, a global advocate for persecuted Christians, wrote in The Hill, a DC-based news outlet on American politics, on Saturday: “As Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to meet with President Trump this week, a question is looming: what will President Trump say about the rise in brutal persecution of Christians, Muslims and other religious minorities in India? Can we expect the President to bring this issue to light, or let it linger in the shadows? Having recently returned from India, I witnessed firsthand accounts of pastors imprisoned and churches attacked by mobs of Hindu radicals, not to mention the abysmal saga of Compassion International, wherein the Indian government’s crackdown-on this and other organizations-has led to tens of thousands of children throughout India losing access to medical care, meals and tuition.”

There are no meetings scheduled between US Congressman Royce and Modi so far, and officials maintained that this will be the first Modi-Trump meeting and the two leaders will focus on the “big picture”.

In March this year, Royce and more than 100 members of the US Congress had written to Home Minister Rajnath Singh, asking him to allow US-based charity Compassion International to continue its work in India.

Compassion International was forced to terminate its service to India after nearly 50 years of work there, after the Ministry of Home Affairs issued an inter-bank circular preventing all commercial banks in India from processing CI’s wire transfers without prior Ministry approval. As a result, Compassion was unable to process the funds it needed to continue, and was forced to close its sponsorship programmes on March 15 this year.

In the letter written in March, US Congressmen led by Royce had said that as long-time supporters of the US-India partnership, “we have worked diligently to deepen ties between our two countries. As the largest and oldest democracies in the world, India and the United States share bonds rooted in political pluralism and respect for the rule of law. It is with this in mind that we write to express our deep concern over the lack of transparency and consistency in your government’s enforcement of the Foreign Contributions Regulations Act.”

Compassion International has worked in India since 1968, and its programmes support over 145,000 Indian children, providing critical tutoring, health and nutrition, and medical services. Being a faith-based child sponsorship NGO based in Colorado, it has served nearly two million children living in extreme poverty across 26 countries worldwide.

In February 2016, the Indian government had issued an order against Compassion, preventing funds from reaching its local church partners in India. “These restrictions appear to be religiously motivated. Compassion is an unapologetically Christian organization that seeks to serve children in poverty as a response to its faith. The decision is disappointing because Compassion accepts and serves children and families in India of all faith backgrounds and rigorously follows Indian law,” an official of Compassion International said.

In March, Santiago Jimmy Mellado, CEO of Compassion International, wrote to its sponsors, “As we navigate this difficult moment in Compassion’s history, I am flooded with emotions. I am heartbroken for sure, over the 147,000 babies, children, young adults and mothers who will no longer receive the benefits of Compassion’s program. I am distraught over the partnerships with 589 churches that will come to an end. I am concerned for our 127 staff members who have committed their careers to helping the poorest of the poor in their own communities.”

Indian government officials, however, maintained that any NGO, foreign or Indian, has to operate in India, or for that matter anywhere else in the world, within the laws of the country. Officials have also said that the government had been fully transparent in this regard, including in conversations with Compassion International’s officials concerned.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. C
    Christodan Takri
    Jun 28, 2017 at 8:52 pm
    As the head of country Modiji is responsible and courageous to face all kinds of challenges and issues globally. He is now world leader.
    Reply
    1. S
      swami jyoti
      Jun 27, 2017 at 11:43 pm
      From: Dr. Mrs Hilda Raja, VADODARA Gujarat, June 26, 2017: (continued) …..I am a Christian I LIKE TO CHALLENGE David Curry--and tell him to get his statistics straight where is the rise of brutal cution? Do not lie and use deception for spreading Christianity--which you think is the god given command to you and the Christian NGOs. Do not force yourself and your compassion on us.
      Reply
      1. S
        swami jyoti
        Jun 27, 2017 at 11:41 pm
        From: Dr. Mrs Hilda Raja, VADODARA Gujarat, June 26, 2017: The crackdown on NGOs should have been done long ago. What are the NGOs indulging in? All to my knowledge were covertly and overtly indulging in conversion. After all if, really these NGOs are interested in charity--why INDIA--is the world poor all congregated in India only? Go to where the poor are, leave India alone. Do not indulge in deception and under the guise of charity to convert. Tens of thousands of children throughout India losing access to medical care, meals and tuition, according to David Curry, president and CEO of Open Doors USA why is India the TAREGT FOR THE COMPASSION? Should compassion not be directed to all those who are in dire need? David Curry states that there is rise in brutal cution of Christians, Muslims and other religious minorities in India. I am a Christian I LIKE TO CHALLENGE David Curry--and tell him to get his statistics straight where is the rise of brutal cution? Do not lie and
        Reply
        1. G
          George Cruz
          Jun 27, 2017 at 4:36 am
          Many of the businesses and many of the senators/reps looking after country's interests rather the Christian charity organizations which are involved in heinous conversion activities for profits. Unlike many African and South American countries, India has 5000 years old Hindu religion, well advanced Hindu culture, and doesn't foreign religions.
          Reply
          1. R
            Ram
            Jun 27, 2017 at 4:26 am
            Just like Indian politicians have very little leeway in internal matters of USA, like a wall building or banning muslims from entering USA, politicians from US also have very little say in internal matters of India. Modi can be asked only on matters related to international relations and US-India trade/immigration etc. not about some dubious NGOs and facilitating Hindu conversions by church using foreign unaccounted/illegal money. Will these pro-church politicians agree if India meddles in their policies in abortion etc? They also know that it is no more maculay congres-commi dominated junta, but a popularly elected nationalist government which can't be arm twisted or bribed!
            Reply
            1. R
              Raju
              Jun 27, 2017 at 3:07 am
              American Hindus group sending millions of US$ to India for RSS extremist group, their radical Hindus agenda implementation in India and other world. why RSS dominated RSS Modi Govt. not banned? NGO this is only for charity works, never for conversation. Christianity never do conversion by the money, but we are supporting those needy, and poor people india by all form. Christian conversion change mind as righteous person. believe in Christ. The cons ution takes every care to protect the religious minority community. In order that culture and religion of the minority community is not swamped by these of the majority community.Keep India’s cons ution alive, do not try to implement of RSS Hindu radical agenda against minority their believe , their religious Patrice and their eating habit, The provisions relating to “Right of Freedom of Religion” of the Articles 25 28 of the Cons ution of India make India a secular state.
              Reply
              1. R
                Ram
                Jun 27, 2017 at 4:37 am
                American Hindus all have Indian roots and most of their places of worships are in India. They can't be compared with some alien christian groups doing soul harvest all over the world! By teh way most Indian NRIs are either Indian citizens or Over seas citizens of India having many legitimate rights back home. That can't be said about many western christian groups. The aim is stop them from rice bag related harvest and use real spiritual/philosophical stuff if they have any to get new adherents like Hindu/Buddhist groups do in west. Look at ISCON they wont buy souls, rather many westerners give their hard earned fortune to become part of them! Show us one christian who became christian like that in India! Rice bags are not they way to spread spirituality/religion! Don't mistake, most Hindu temples in India serve free food/prasad to all, not necessarily to convert them! Only they don't do propaganda on such 'service'!
                Reply
                1. R
                  Ram
                  Jun 27, 2017 at 4:48 am
                  Sir, Christian population in India is less than 2.5 percent. Most of them are very very poor converts due to various reasons, major being as pay back for economic help and misleading propaganda around Hinduism by conversion agents. That said, how can one explain disproportionate ownership of financial/real estate assets by Church? Where did the money come from? Is it not true that In India with hardly 2 percent christians, Church groups are the biggest land owners? Otherhand, most Hindu temples are looted by 'secular' governments, when poor Hindu devotees donate their hard earned money to their temples. Some one need to explain how these things are happening with the 'secularism' as a convenient tool to destabilize native faiths! In such treachery, all alien groupings be it communists, islamists or church groups, all have joined hands, although they in world level they are fighting their wars of civilizations! Looks like finally Hindu/Buddhist/jain/Sikhs have woken up!
                  Reply
                2. S
                  S.K. Express
                  Jun 27, 2017 at 2:46 am
                  A poor article - does not even state the Indian government's argument. The goal of CI is evangelism. They have not been following India's laws and hence booted out. I strongly recommend that CI use this $45 million that it wants to spend in India for conversion on buying health insurance for uninsured Americans.
                  Reply
                  1. S
                    S. Gowrishankar,
                    Jun 27, 2017 at 12:28 am
                    We believe the Government of India and not the NGO. It is better the Congressmen in the USA mind their business. India will do what is best for it and its interests. None have to provide any advise. This NGO is shut is for good reason and many more need to be closed.
                    Reply
                    1. Load More Comments