Court stenographer walks out of proceedings, says her cab is waiting

The court, which described the scene created by the stenographer as a "very sorry state of affairs", said she "hijacked" a live video conference proceedings in the presence of several lawyers, giving a "very shabby impression" to the public at large present there.

By: PTI | New Delhi | Published:May 31, 2017 2:37 pm
Court stenographer, stenographer walks out, Tis Hazari court The judge, who recorded in detail the conduct of the stenographer in the order, said the court staff created hindrance to the proceedings.

Have you ever heard of a court staff “hijacking” judicial proceedings? The peculiar situation was witnessed last week at the Tis Hazari courts complex here when a special court dealing with corruption cases was recording the evidence of a CBI witness from Kolkata through live video conferencing and a stenographer abruptly walked out, telling the court that she was leaving and her cab was waiting outside.

Taking strong note of the act, the court said the woman stenographer dared to “disrespect the chair” and “undermined the authority” of the court by leaving a live hearing. The court, which described the scene created by the stenographer as a “very sorry state of affairs”, said she “hijacked” a live video conference proceedings in the presence of several lawyers, giving a “very shabby impression” to the public at large present there.

The judge, who recorded in detail the conduct of the stenographer in the order, said the court staff created hindrance to the proceedings and the presiding officer as well as lawyers present in the room had to sit idle till another stenographer arrived. “It is pertinent to mention that court had to wait for another 5­10 minutes for arrangement of other stenographer. The scene created by the stenographer… gave an impression as if the proceedings have been hijacked and the same had to be stopped,” the judge said in a written order.

The incident happened last week when the stenographer got up at 4:25 PM and said she wanted to leave as her cab was waiting outside. When the judge reminded her that the court timing were not yet over, she responded saying that by the time she marks her attendance at the superintendent’s office before leaving, it will be 5 PM.

Giving further details of the incident in the order, the judge said the woman was warned that she cannot leave in between the proceedings even when the other stenographer, who had a fractured leg, was doing his pending work in the regular court room.

The judicial officer said the regular stenographer could have medical complications if he was called in the video conferencing room with his fractured leg. Without paying heed to it, the woman staffer said “mujhe jaana hai, mujhe jaana hai (I need to leave, I need to leave)”, and told the presiding officer that he may call another stenographer from the administration officer, the judge noted in the order.

The order noted that she was again warned by the judge but “she continued with her adamancy to go and started arguing” inside the court room in the presence of several lawyers. She also said she was suffering from pain in her right hand and had complained about it during the recording of the witness’ statement.

Terming the stenographer’s act as a gross misconduct amounting to dereliction of duty, the judge said it also led to undermining the authority of the court and disrespect to the chair. The judge sent the matter to the District and Sessions Judge (Headquarters), the head of lower judiciary, for taking appropriate action against the delinquent staff. “Though contempt of the court proceedings could have been initiated by this court to maintain the judicial decorum, but this court opted not to chose the same in order to maintain judicial restraints and instead thought it appropriate that the matter should be reported to the District and Sessions Judge (HQ),” the court said.

After some time, the woman staffer returned to the court room, prompting the judge to ask why she was back again. The judge said “it is not her whims or choice to opt for work or not to do work or shirk work” and asked her to report to the superintendent. The court then informed administrative officials about the situation. The court proceedings resumed when the regular stenographer arrived with the help of a walker and completed the work.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. S
    S C Gupta
    Jun 2, 2017 at 7:52 am
    Things never are and never will be perfect but this sort of gross and blatant indiscipline must not go unpunished just because the person concerned is a female. That's the bottom line.
    Reply
    1. S
      shubhankar banarjee
      Jun 2, 2017 at 2:37 am
      The w system of lower judiciary or all courts except supreme court in india are hughly inefficient huge vaccancy nepotistic selection of judges as well as promotion has made the justice to common man so expensive and impossible that people think that going to court means going to and end of life. The appeal itself lies for so long that in almost 90 percent cases person dies before even case closes. Civil cases are so badly dealt that if u r a goonda or neta than u can capture any land u want. Also thia sorry state of affair of court responsibility lies more to our honourable judges than government. No video conferencing of casea allowed?? Why because it will expose them. I have read many times ur dexision is made by some other judge and on paper recore is signed by other. ITs MOST OPAQUE ins ution of india. Some judge told pea ccan only be male and reproduce by teara of each other. Ao this is level of judges in india
      Reply
      1. M
        May Flower
        Jun 1, 2017 at 11:28 am
        Worthless news. May be that lady is mentally ill, she has a sick child, or plain irresponsible. Reporter's mentality is (as a vernacular saying) - - if a banyan tree sprouts in YOUR mother's behind, it is a view worth seeing. Or does he/she wants to tell us that Indian judiciary is rotten.
        Reply
        1. H
          HOMER
          Jun 1, 2017 at 8:20 am
          She must be meeting her lover. NOTHING else would prompt her to so irresponsible and so obstinate!
          Reply
          1. S
            Seshadri Iyengar
            Jun 1, 2017 at 5:53 am
            In this day and age, do we need stenographers at all. Judges should opt for record and type or may be direct conversion of speech into print
            Reply
            1. A
              Amit
              Jun 1, 2017 at 7:16 am
              Have you ever been to a court. Do you know how long evidence /depositions are. If Judges start recording the Depositions the w proceedings will be elongated. Judges won't be able to hear to matter properly and grant relief. There is a huge vacancies of court clerical staff in courts all over country. Even judges have to see multiple courts/administrative functions. Still, there a no recruitment of Judges and Court staff as required in almost all the states.
              Reply
            2. S
              S.P.Chakravarty
              May 31, 2017 at 7:46 pm
              Judges and lawyers have to learn to be brief, to the point, instead of expecting court staff to stay without pay listening to drivel.
              Reply
              1. N
                nagarajabillur
                May 31, 2017 at 5:31 pm
                Generally lower judiciary is not very honest and efficient. They lose respect and fear. I have nothing against this judge. He could be the best. But that is the unfortunate situation. Very sad indeed.
                Reply
                1. P
                  P prabhakar
                  Jun 27, 2017 at 1:29 pm
                  Do not generalise sir There may be black sheep but such black sheep are not more in lower judiciary. Obvously those are the persons' who get elevations with political clout and extraneous considerations
                  Reply
                2. C
                  Citizen
                  May 31, 2017 at 5:26 pm
                  Indiscipline is rampant in the nation and many link that to their birth and ociation with other groups and the collective strength of those memberships etc It is high time to clip these things and suitable under taking at the time of recruitment should be taken so that with out much waste of time their services/benefits may be terminated at once. Jaihind
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments