• Associate Sponsor

Bengal doctor suspended for Facebook post on govt ‘pressure’

The post attracted several comments, with other doctors sharing their stories about working in government hospitals and dealing with the vector-borne disease.

Written by SWEETY KUMARI | Kolkata | Updated: November 12, 2017 7:03 am
West Bengal, Bengal Doctor suspected, Criticism of WB government, Arunachal Dutta Choudhury, India news, Indian Express Dr Arunachal Dutta Choudhury. (Source: Facebook)

The West Bengal government has suspended a doctor employed with the Barasat district hospital after he put out a Facebook post complaining about the alleged “pressure” from the government even as the state faces a dengue outbreak.

The October 8 post in Bengali by Dr Arunachal Dutta Choudhury, a chest physician in the general medicine department of the government hospital in North 24 Parganas district, reads, “October 6 was my admission (duty) day. From 9 am that day to 9 am the next day, I was responsible for patient admissions, referrals and even death. After spending 24 hours (on duty), what will my condition be?

“Every patient was suffering from fever. Many of them had blood reports stating that they had dengue… But doctors couldn’t attend to them as there were around 500 patients… District health authorities have been saying that the hospital has all necessary arrangements (to tackle dengue). But the hospital management is helpless. There is an unwritten instruction to hide the fact that the hospital lacks necessary facilities. Or else, there will be pressure.”

He tagged two pictures with the post – one that showed a white board with details of the number of patients and staff in the ward and another, according to which 250 patients were admitted under Choudhury and three nurses assigned to assist him.

The post attracted several comments, with other doctors sharing their stories about working in government hospitals and dealing with the vector-borne disease.

On Friday, November 10, the state health department initiated an inquiry against Choudhury and sent him a suspension letter, which called his post “derogatory” and with “unverified and misleading statistics”.

When contacted, Choudhury said, “I joined the government service in 1983. I am approaching 63, the patient burden on me was too much. People are looking at it as suspension, but I am relieved to get such a holiday… I am a government servant and have to abide by their order,” he said. Calling himself a “poet”, Choudhury went on to say, “Now I will only share romantic poems on social media because they won’t offend anyone.”

While Minister of State for Health Chandrima Bhattacharya refused to comment, Director of Health Services Biswaranjan Satpathy was unreachable on phone. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee holds the Health portfolio.

Reacting to the doctor’s suspension, BJP national secretary Rahul Sinha told The Sunday Express, “Dr Dutta must appeal in the High Court. There is no democracy left in Bengal. The way the government is trying to maintain secrecy proves its failure in controlling dengue.”

The recent dengue outbreak has become a political issue in the state, with the CPM and the BJP criticising the government for its alleged inability to fight the menace.

While higher officials of the state health department confirmed at least 40 deaths to The Indian Express, two days later, on October 30, the Chief Minister said only 13 of these were confirmed dengue deaths. According to government officials, over 2,000 people across the state have been diagnosed with dengue since January.

Calling Choudhury’s suspension an assault on the freedom of speech and expression, a group of associations representing doctors has written to Governor Keshari Nath Tripathi, seeking the withdrawal of the doctor’s suspension. “He was one of the physicians leading the fight against… dengue and other febrile illnesses in… North 24 Parganas…” the letter read.

Over the last few months, at least seven people across Bengal have faced action over their Facebook posts.

Last month, two people – businessman Debojit Roy and bank employee Anupam Tarafdar – were arrested in Balurghat town for their Facebook posts, in which they critisised police and administration for imposing traffic restrictions during Durga puja.

In July this year, a teenager’s Facebook had triggered riots in West Bengal’s Basirhat subdivision, following which two minors were arrested. The same month, one Tarun Sengupta was arrested for allegedly uploading a fake video of a Muslim police officer beating a Hindu man.

BJP leader Nupur Sharma and RSS ideologue Rakesh Sinha too were recently booked by the Kolkata Police for their allegedly “objectionable” Facebook posts.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. C
    Nov 12, 2017 at 6:56 pm
    Arrogance at its highest. Instead of accepting the reality and initiating the steps to correct the situation the foolish government and the fools who voted for that now suffer with one less doctor. Rulers have funds to glorify themselves but no funds to improve the health care of the nation. The same thing applies to judiciary too we do not have sufficient judges/investigation agencies but ready to blame the judiciary for delays. Adopt FP and rulers should think linking government's subsidies/benefits to two kids otherwise they loose everything. Jaihind
    1. K
      Kumar T
      Nov 12, 2017 at 11:53 am
      TODAY IS SUNDAY - - - FRONT PAGE OF IE... Bengal doctor suspended for Facebook post on govt 'pressure' - - Friends Citizens - this is Not NEW. Are you surprised? Is there any 'plausible' or 'substance' reason for a reasonably matured person - to be Surprised? No! Surely Not. ... the chain of events flowing incessantly - every moment, everywhere ... the pitch (of all things, political or otherwise) Rises... to awkward and un-acceptable ODD heights and corners till it bursts, explodes. ... to be specific - honey, milk and other nutritions pass from ordinary lay women and men (in the style of 'ballot-box' consents) and flow into the 'bellies' of figures and leaders - who fight for the 'licence' to serve or to rule as the post-election incidents prove. ... this is simply a page in history - recent or past - when we often and often, find out - THE ELECTED LEADERS AND FIGURES - they grow a habit of - A REVERSE-GEAR system - to CHOKE THE PEOPLE, THOSE VERY PERSONS - who had Nourished them!
      1. Urmila Duhan
        Nov 12, 2017 at 11:47 am
        As a government servant, the doctor is supposed to be the part of the problem plaguing the system. As a government servant, the doctor should've focussed on how to help the government deal with the problem and not just focus on the problem of feeling over worked. As a doctor, he should've suggested ways in which doctors on a 24 hr emergency duty can improve their energy levels through diet and nutrition and through proper exercise regimen instead of blaming the system for his poor energy levels and inability to deal with medical emergency situations.
        1. Rajat Kumar
          Nov 12, 2017 at 12:20 pm
          Shame on you for your insensitive thoughts, are the doctors not human can't they even complain about yhe system. People like you make the mockery of democracy and will be first one to cry when centre government does the same. Pity on your thoughts.
          1. M
            Nov 12, 2017 at 1:19 pm
            ic comments --- to say the least.
            1. N
              Navin Machado
              Nov 13, 2017 at 1:04 am
              You are stupid if lack of infra structure can be made up by over working one senior person and
            2. C
              Nov 12, 2017 at 11:31 am
              This is a classic case for political students to study and do thesis and come up with solution. The image of state government is coming in way in honest disclosing which is detrimental to people. Tomorrow if there is a volcanic eruption are we going to say people are burning trash? Something like disease specially vector born are complicated. Global climatic change , population, drainage problem, imbalance of fona flora so many things could go wrong. Ideally State Central Govt. needs to work together. Forget electoral gains or party politics, people know our democratic system can't function 100 until all are educated and have the mindset above regionalism, religion, caste or language, which is not the case. So please follow the age old saying honesty is the best policy, as much as possible, it will benefit people, democracy the basis on which politicians earn money. Don't end up creating a system when democracy has to morphed into some other form before due time.
              1. M
                Nov 12, 2017 at 10:55 am
                mamataa for satyamev jayate?
                1. Load More Comments