As PM Modi visits Israel, Chorus from Gaza: ‘He should have come to Palestine’

Tobail, who owns a multimedia firm, is referring to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who arrived in Israel Tuesday for the first visit to the country by an Indian Prime Minister

Written by Shubhajit Roy | Gaza Strip | Updated: July 5, 2017 8:35 am
israel, india israel relations, narendra modi, modi in israel, india israel history, india news, indian express news Tel Aviv :Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during welcome ceremony upon arrival in Ben Gurion airport near Tel Aviv, Israel, Tuesday. PTI Photo

Inside a windowless room near the Erez border crossing between Israel and the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip, 85 km from Jerusalem, Fathi Tobail is a disappointed man. “He should have come to Palestine,” says the 53-year-old, shaking his head. “We believe India has good cooperation with Palestine, and we wanted him to come to Gaza as well,” says Tobail, wearing the traditional keffiyeh.

Tobail, who owns a multimedia firm, is referring to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who arrived in Israel Tuesday for the first visit to the country by an Indian Prime Minister. Unlike previous visits by three Indian leaders — foreign ministers Jaswant Singh in 2000, S M Krishna in 2012 and Sushma Swaraj in 2016 — Modi’s visit is limited to Israel, and does not include Palestine. Married to an Indian, Tobail says he has stayed in Chandigarh and now produces short films and manages websites in Gaza.

“India can cooperate in the field of electricity. If he had visited Palestine, we would have submitted a request to him about the scarcity of power in Gaza,” he says, pointing to the fan that doesn’t work. On Tuesday morning, there was no electricity, too. “Power cuts are very common in Gaza,” says Tobail.

The one-hour, 20-minute ride to Erez is smooth, on a four-lane expressway, where lush greenery on either side leads to the imposing, concrete crossing at Erez, with a glass facade. On the Israeli side of the immigration facility, a lone woman officer is playing “candy crush” on her cellphone. Two families wait in the lobby, with a little girl chewing on a plastic teddy bear. Photography is not allowed.

The immigration officer takes a hard look at the passport before issuing a stern reminder: “The gates close for foreigners by 3 pm.” Informed that the Israeli foreign ministry had specified 3.30 pm, she corrects herself: “Until 3.30 pm.”

The “other side” lies past the immigration checkpoints through a narrow labyrinth of grey concrete, and a “tuk-tuk” ride through a tunnel-like path, caged with wire and steel. In Gaza, an officer sits under a poster of Yasser Arafat on the wall, and a map of Gaza Strip. Nearby, the Al Awda cafeteria advertises “free WiFi”. The cafeteria also flaunts Bisci chocolate biscuits, date bars, Sirma mineral water and Shuga wet wipes.

Tobail’s office is another taxi ride away, past Palestinian immigration, controlled by Hamas. At the office, journalist Suhada Hammad, 25, echoes the disappointment.

“We expected that he will come to Palestine, and to Gaza. He should have come to see the situation here, talk to us about our issues, lives. Unfortunately, this time, it has not happened. Another time, we hope,” says Suhada, wearing a blue dress and a head scarf with yellow-and-blue floral prints.

Then there’s Ali Mohammad Abushbak, 25, who is keen on getting an admission to Jamia Millia Islamia’s mass communications programme. “It’s very sad that Modi did not come to Palestine. A lot of people believe the story of Israel, but what about the Palestine story? We are feeling discriminated by this approach of the Indian government,” says Ali.

Israeli officials say that Hamas, which controls Gaza, is a terrorist organisation. According to Mark Sofer, a senior official in Israel’s foreign ministry, there is no difference between Lashkar-e-Toiba and Hamas.

Israel’s concerns resonate in the security checks on the way back. Here, bags are emptied completely — pens, keys, handkerchieves, headphones and open laptops are placed on a large plastic tray, so that each item is visible. Then, there are body scanners and more security checks.

A Swedish woman, who works for a Norwegian humanitarian organisation in Gaza, is worried that security personnel would confiscate the Swiss knife gifted by her husband. But as her tray arrives, her face lights up — the knife is there.

Outside, a blue poster with an image of one hand clasping another, reads: “www.helpmegaza.com, Call @ 1800-800-319”.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. B
    Bert Brech
    Jul 5, 2017 at 2:49 pm
    The Palestinians and other Arabs have always sided with Pakistan against India and either openly supported China against India or refused to side with India. All the boundless sycophancy with which Indian governments larded the Arabs starting with Nehru never changed the Arab position of opposing India. All that lionising of Nasser ! Israel, by contrast, even though India always kept it at arms length and until recently did not even have full embassy level relations with it, always sided with India against Pakistan, and rushed emergency supplies to arms to India in 1962 during the Chinese invasion of India. Even then Nehru at first wanted the Israeli aircraft bringing the arms not to have Israeli signs on them so as to avoid offending Muslims and Arabs ! Ben Gurion said: No Israeli signs, no arms. The gutless Nehru of course gave in at once. So Israel has been a great and true friend of India. The only question is, does India deserve it.
    Reply
    1. N
      NKSA
      Jul 5, 2017 at 2:11 pm
      None of the muslim countries supported india on kashmir in IOC for all the support we gave to Palestinians for 70 years. ungrateful bigots want help but betray us on every opportunity
      Reply
      1. S
        sid
        Jul 5, 2017 at 2:00 pm
        these are same palestanians who side with Pakistanis in OIC. India should infact help Israel get rid of them.
        Reply
        1. P
          Preeti Rathaur
          Jul 5, 2017 at 1:22 pm
          Every country look after her interests. In the present circumstances, Indian interests are better served by aligning with Israel and US.
          Reply
          1. S
            salam kahn
            Jul 5, 2017 at 1:01 pm
            What is common between them? Kashmir is India's west bank.
            Reply
            1. N
              NKSA
              Jul 5, 2017 at 2:05 pm
              Paki pigs cannot differentiate between issues. For them India is unfinished agenda of gazwa-e-hind. islamists do not rest till the world is under caliphate. finally bring end of world.
              Reply
            2. R
              rddy
              Jul 5, 2017 at 12:39 pm
              i am not sure weather palestine people have asked for Modi visit, but surely islamic express asss is burning as Modi is the first Prime Minister to visit israel, previous congress governments never wants to have any relation with israel to appease indian muslims, that was the irony of India
              Reply
              1. A
                AlsoIndian
                Jul 5, 2017 at 1:21 pm
                This is not true! The previous governments were supportive of the cause of Palestine because Israel - as a country - did never exist. Israelis were expelled from the current Israel/Palestine by the Greek 2100 years ago in a so called exodus. The country then came under different rules, among them the last one was when British forces occupied Turkish controlled Palestine after the WWI. Since the Jews were subject of atrocities by the s (whom Savarkar and Gowalkar openly praised), British declared in 1917 that they will a state call Israel - which never ever was - from the Palestine. At that time Palestine had Muslim, Christian and Jewish populations all living in peace. Jewish formed 7 of the population. As Israel was created, they received all the mighty support from the USA and UK to supress, kill and expell the native Palestinians from their land. For your information, almost 80 of the current Israeli population are immigrants and not the real natives.
                Reply
                1. A
                  AlsoIndian
                  Jul 5, 2017 at 1:27 pm
                  But as we all know, the Hindutvavadis are real opportunists. Savarkar and Gowalkar admired s over their killing of Jews and said that it was fair to do that because people of two believes can't live together in Germany. So brutal and inhuman right? They also said that a similar role model must be followed in India to eliminate all other religions (other than Hinduism). On the contrary, now Mr. Modi is trying to be friend with Israel - mainly because they have found Muslims as a common enemy. So Modi is a great opportunists! If he denounces Gowalkar and Savarkar - who were pro Holocaust - then we will believe that he is fair. He never will! So disgusting!
                  1. A
                    AlsoIndian
                    Jul 5, 2017 at 1:27 pm
                    I don't know why Indian express is deleting the word N a z i z .
                    1. N
                      NKSA
                      Jul 5, 2017 at 2:09 pm
                      Peddling half-truths. Isrealis are original inhabitants of the land. All of middleeast was a jewish land. after the barbaric invasions and massacres by mohameds army most of them died or converted or driven away. Jews have a legitimate right to exist and have a country. Unless Palestinians and muslims agree and accept that there will be no peace for them. They should learn to live in peace and let other live in peace.
                    2. M
                      m
                      Jul 5, 2017 at 4:01 pm
                      Reply
                    3. A
                      Ari C
                      Jul 5, 2017 at 12:37 pm
                      Nothing against the Palestinians. You have the Arabs to blame who always support Pakistan sponsored resolutions on Kashmir at OIC .... dia got zero return after supporting Arabs at the expense of Israel for 70 years.
                      Reply
                      1. T
                        The Observer
                        Jul 5, 2017 at 12:36 pm
                        Enough of this double speak by the media. Just to give other point of view you would go to any extent, catch hold of all and sundry or even create one. Just tell us what did India achieve by supporting Palestine in the past 40 years. Even Palestine do not know who calls the shots with so many breakaway groups. Had we only engaged with Israel over the ,last 40-50 years we could have done wonders in improving our security, agriculture and water management.
                        Reply
                        1. Load More Comments