Amit Shah in Goa: ‘More lynchings took place in 2011-13’

To a question on the “growing apprehension” across the country over the government’s apparent lack of effective action against the perpetrators of lynching, Amit Shah asked, “Do you know of any such incident where arrests have not been made?"

Written by Smita Nair | Panjim | Updated: July 2, 2017 7:30 pm
amit shah, amit shah on lynching, amit shah goa, bjp, amit shah mob violence, gau rakshaks, india news, indian express news BJP president Amit Shah arrives at Dabolim airport in Goa on Saturday. (Source: PTI Photo)

BJP PRESIDENT Amit Shah on Saturday defended the Narendra Modi government’s record in the face of questions in some quarters on mob lynchings, many of them allegedly by cow vigilantes, and said more incidents of lynching took place between 2011 and 2013, when the Congress-led UPA was in power at the Centre. Replying to a question on lynching, Shah said, “I do not want to compare and undermine the current incidents of lynching…. I am also serious. (But) there have been more lynchings in 2011, 2012, and 2013. Humaare teen saal main jitne lynching hue hain usse zyada hue hain ek ek saal main. Magar kabhi yeh sawaal nahi uttha thha (There have been more incidents of lynching in each of these years than in NDA’s three years.)”

To a question on the “growing apprehension” across the country over the government’s apparent lack of effective action against the perpetrators of lynching, Shah asked, “Do you know of any such incident where arrests have not been made? I do not have any answer to ‘apprehension’…. There is no apprehension anywhere in the country.” Indicating that incidents of lynching, being law and order issues, are a state subject, Shah, who is on a two-day visit to Goa, said, “Aur ab (since NDA government took office) sawaal kis tarah se uthaye jaate hain? Mohammad Akhlaq ka death hua. Uttar Pradesh mein Samajwadi Party ki sarkar hain. Law and order state subject hain. Jimmedari Samajwadi Party sarkar ki hain. Aur dharna Dilli mein Modi sarkar ke saamne nikalenge. Kya fashion hai? (And how are questions raised now? There was an SP government in UP when Akhlaq died. The responsibility is the SP government’s. But protest marches are taken out in Delhi, in front of the Modi government. What is this fashion?)”

Shah met state BJP leaders and coalition partners on Saturday morning. Later in the evening, at a hotel in capital Panaji, he met a gathering comprising professionals from various sectors, special invitees and potential voters, among others. He threw the floor open to questions at the beginning of the interaction. The questions touched upon various subjects — from real estate regulation to the state of education, and from agitation in Darjeeling for a separate state of Gorkhaland to nationalisation of rivers, among others.

On the subject of “beef ban”, specifically to Goa, when a local remarked that “yeh beef ban Goa mein nehin chalega (this beef ban won’t work in Goa)”, Shah smiled and said, “Good you brought this up…. Media ko isme ras hai. The ban was imposed in 1976 by a previous government. The BJP never imposed beef ban in Goa. But no one put this question on beef ban to the Congress.” To a question on the BJP’s plan for minorities in the state, Shah said, “In states such as Gujarat, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh, the population of minorities is more than the total population of Goa. We have been governing there for more than 15 years and the minorities face no problem. In fact…a sense of fear is created between the minorities and the party.”

Asked about the Kashmir crisis, the BJP president said that from the news one feels that Kashmir is gone from India but nothing like that is occurring on the ground. Maintaining that the situation in the Valley cannot be assessed in four or five months, he said, “Kashmir has seen ups and downs since 1989 — the law and order situation has always been boiling. You feel Kashmir has gone (out of our control): neither is it gone, nor will it ever go…. Our security forces will control the situation very, very soon and no one will have the courage to ever take on us again.” On the Gorkhaland issue, Shah said, “I do not hold any government responsible for the fights emerging from acceptance of any language. The Government of India cannot stop these (language politics)…. This will now have to be handled by the three sides —- the Gorkhas, Mamata Banerjee (West Bengal government), and the Indian government.”

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. D
    Jul 5, 2017 at 10:43 am
    Nobody questioned? Who was supposed to question? Opposition right. Wonder who was in opposition? Oh, that's right! Hypocrite liars!
    1. N
      Narayana hospital
      Jul 4, 2017 at 7:39 am
      Do you want to donate your kidney for financial crisis,well a chance us here,donate your kidney and get full payment, we are buying kidneys to willing donors 2 crore India rupees,the donors we get free donors cards Contact Dr.Abdul from Narayana Hospital. Phone number : 918904381599 Email: narayanahospital619 Thanks
      1. R
        Jul 2, 2017 at 7:37 pm
        It is unfortunate such comment from the President of the Leading Political Party. He should understand that"Two Wrongs Cannot make one Correct". The problem is country and various states are ruled by the goons only because the common people will stay away from politics and will only look for vested interests. Therefore, such statements are only expected from various goons across the country.
        1. P
          Jul 2, 2017 at 4:04 pm
          Carried out by BJP for electoral gains. Why only just before elections. Indirectly seems BJP conspired for its power hunger for satisfy itself. BJP can do anything with anyone, it belongs to none. See Advani,Joshi. Jo apno ke niahi hosake wo kisi aur ke kya honge.....dhongi BJP Tto hide their failures cow is raised. Ram ram na paraya mal apna
          1. J
            Jul 2, 2017 at 3:53 pm
            Today under BJP we Hindus feel proud to be Indians as they have corrected the path country should be taking. From Hindi language to ones iden y to correcting moral compass. It is unfortunate that country with its historical imported Religions has dominated us and torn the country apart. With large sums of money injected into Christians and Muslim communities there has been divisions caused which the Congress has supported due to its own lack of iden y. There is nothing wrong in saying or following the Hindutava teachings and the other religions should align themselves, not the other way round where we have always been accommodating and trampled upon by the minority religions. I have been to GOA many times and hate seeing Christians behaving with arrogance and considering themselves descendants of Portuguese believing that they are Europeans. At times I have been treated as a second class citizen in my own country. BJP has given us sense of belonging and national pride Jai Hind
            1. P
              Jul 2, 2017 at 4:00 pm
              Your name is Jack, you claim to be hindu. What is your iden y, confirm not me but yourself
            2. A
              Jul 2, 2017 at 3:37 pm
              When illiterates and goondas rule a country, what more can you expect? Thu thu on Amit Shah, a goon, rioter, murderer and a threat to the country.
              1. P
                Jul 2, 2017 at 3:35 pm
                Abbey mote, yaaddasht kamzir ho gayi ya apne hawa mahal uda raha hai. Koi is saand se pucho bhai records hain kya? Aur kahan se honge? Bcoz this fat a s s is blatantly lying. If lynchings hapnd in 2011-13 he and his God Modi were in opposition. How come they kept quiet then? More important thing is lynchings are increasing just like ceasefires and terror attacks on our armed forces ever since these fat sos took over. Their constant anti Muslim jabeerings are giving more freedem to Gaugoondas and their other riotwala, electionwala goondas to do just whatever they want. He should better shut the up and feel sorry for the liss of lives, to do the least. These a s s h o l e s like Amit Shah feel pain after confirming a deceased's religion, caste, gotra and more.
                1. S
                  Jul 2, 2017 at 3:29 pm
                  so mr.amit shah you wanted have more lynching deaths than 2011-2013. please don't compare but stop this nonsense and book the criminals and hang them to death.
                  1. Load More Comments