Dalhousie to Dara Shukoh: On the road with the ‘good’ Mughal

Dara Shukoh is said to have been a philosopher, a tolerant and pluralist prince, who found common threads in Islam and Hinduism.

Written by Devyani Onial | Updated: February 8, 2017 11:15 am
Dara Shukoh, dara shikoh, aurangzeb, Dara Shukoh road, dalhousie road, name change, road name, road name change, lord dalhousie,dalhousie road renamed, dara shikoh road, who was dara shikoh, mughal history, mughal prince, mughal emperor, Muslim kings, Muslims, Hindus, Hindu right wing, Indian Express Dara Shukoh

HE MAY have lost out to his brother in the battle of thrones, but centuries after his death, Dara Shukoh is staging a comeback in popular imagination. He has uprooted British Governor General Dalhousie from a road in central Delhi and the Indian Council of Cultural Relations has plans to host a seminar dedicated to him soon.

So, who was the philosopher-prince who has often been called the greatest syncretic of India? Would India’s future, as some claim, have looked any different, would a deeper understanding between Hindus and Muslims and a stronger Mughal front kept away the British, and would Partition have been avoidable had the “tolerant and pluralist” Dara acceded to the throne instead of the puritanical and “religious zealot” Aurangzeb?

Historians are divided over the answer, but all agree that no two princes could have been as unlike as heir apparent Dara Shukoh, the first and favourite son of Shah Jahan and favoured brother of Jahanara, and Aurangzeb, his third son. They also agree that his name is often erroneously spelt as Shikoh — the newly named road too carries this spelling — which means terror in Persian, instead of the intended Shukoh, which means grandeur, glory or splendour.

Born in 1615, Dara Shukoh developed an early interest in the esoteric aspects of Islam and mysticism and in Hindu philosophy. He received instructions from Hindu seers and tried to find the common threads in Islam and Hinduism. “Nobody deserves a road named after him more than Dara Shukoh. There is no doubt that he was an outstanding character. He had an intellectual interest in understanding religion, not because he thought he was going to be king but because he was deeply intellectual,” says historian Harbans Mukhia.

But some see the politics behind the New Delhi Municipal Corporation’s move to name a road after him as problematic. “Doing this in normal circumstances would have been fine, it would be a routine matter, but the politics of it is repulsive. It’s this whole good Muslim-bad Muslim idea. Aurangzeb was a bad Muslim, (A P J Abdul) Kalam was a good Muslim, Dara Shukoh was a good Muslim. We reinforce stereotypes with this,” says Mukhia.

Read | Dalhousie Road renamed after Dara Shikoh: Why Hindutva right wingers favour a Mughal prince

The poet-prince, so evocatively etched by Gopal Gandhi in his play Dara Shukoh, authored a number of books, many of which he wrote with the help of scholars. His Majma’ al-Bahrain (Mingling of the Two Oceans), is one of the earliest works to explore both the diversity of religions and a unity of Islam and Hinduism and other religions. He arrived at the conclusion that the “hidden book” mentioned in the Quran was none other than the Upanishads and believed that in order to understand the Quran, one needed to study the Hindu text. With the help of pandits, he also translated 52 volumes of the Upanishads from Sanskrit to Persian into a tome called Sirr-e-Akbar (The Greatest Secret). He even drew an equation between Adam and Brahma — a view which, according to historians, led to him being branded a heretic and to his execution.

In his interest in other religions, Dara, in many ways, took forward the legacy of Akbar. But there were crucial differences. “There was a sea of difference between the two,” says historian Shireen Moosvi. “Dara was all for plurality but was not for reason and rationality like Akbar. Dara moved from mysticism to Hinduism. He tried to see strains of Islam in Hinduism and Hinduism in Islam and very often saw things that weren’t there. But credit has to be given to Dara for his scholarship. Akbar got Hindu texts translated whereas Dara learnt the language and translated them himself with the help of pandits,” she says.

Dara’s story is perhaps never complete without that of his brother Aurangzeb. He was the tolerant pluralist and mystic and Aurangzeb the more religious or more Sunni. “Certainly Dara was not orthodox. In one of his works, he even wrote that paradise is a place that is without mullahs and all the noise they make,” says Moosvi.

Religious consideration perhaps was not top of the mind for the Rajputs who continued to support Aurangzeb and not Dara when the war of succession broke out in 1657 after Shah Jahan fell ill. Though all four brothers — Dara, Aurangzeb, Murad and Shuja — were locked in a bitter war, the first two were the serious contenders. In 1658, Dara was defeated by Aurangzeb and Murad in the Battle of Samugarh near Agra.

Subsequently, Aurangzeb took over Agra Fort and deposed Shah Jahan. Dara was later routed in the Battle of Deorai (near Ajmer) in 1659, after which he fled to Sindh and sought refuge with Malik Jiwan, an Afghan chieftain, whose life had on more than one occasion been saved by the Mughal prince from the wrath of Shah Jahan. But Jiwan betrayed Shukoh and handed him and his second son, Sipihr Shukoh, over to Aurangzeb.

Dara Shukoh was brought to Delhi, placed on a filthy elephant and paraded through the streets of the capital in chains and was subsequently killed by Aurangzeb’s men.

Historians are divided over Dara’s ability to rule had he won. Many point out that he showed his mettle in many of the expeditions that he led but perhaps suffered from the fact that he was mostly kept at court by his father. “We can’t say how he would have been as an administrator as he was not really tested. He was mostly in court and governed his provinces through his deputies,” says historian Irfan Habib.

Dara’s intellectual curiosity and pluralism hold relevance for every age but whether he would have changed India’s course is open to question.

For all the latest Explained News, download Indian Express App

  1. B
    Feb 8, 2017 at 5:36 am
    Basically Aryans long for recognition, especially as a human, because everybody is convinced they are ALIENS, truly and literally. So if somebody recognizes them, then they keep them on the top rung of respect. That Shukoh is said to have a 1000 Aryan concubines. So Aryans love him for recognizing them through those concubines. No shame there for Aryans, as is always!
    1. I
      Feb 8, 2017 at 7:03 am
      Bull sh*t
      1. D
        Feb 10, 2017 at 7:20 am
        Shame on talking like that. Then why do you get angry when we prove that all terrorists are Muslims and hence all Muslims are terrorists. Don't get angry when facts are put in front of you.
        1. M
          Mushtaque Khan
          Feb 9, 2017 at 8:59 pm
          Now IDBI Federal is playing Religous cards by depriving Muslim investors. Let's talk what's happening today in our India. Why talk past? My 20L life time savings illegally held by IDBI Federal and their CFO told Sanpada branch manager--- deprive he is a Muslim. Ha ha I was with the branch manager and he was on speaker! This is ache din????
          1. J
            John Joseph
            Feb 10, 2017 at 7:18 am
            Really? This is not right. We are not Muslims. Muslims do it all the time. 70 Islamic countries regularly discriminates and kidnaps and butcher minority Hindus, Jews, Buddhists, and Christians. Muslims divided India. And they went to convert stan into Islamic and also Bangladesh. And then wiped out minorities there. But Hindus India by choice became secular. And allowed Muslims to grow like pigs from 4% leftover Muslims in 1947 to 20% today. In fact, where ever Muslims are in majority in India they create riots and discriminates against Hindus. But Hindus don't do that. So I am surprised you are not seeing the Acche Sin. May be you like to go to madrasa and get your 72 sheeps.
            1. Load More Comments