More than five years after the Aarushi Talwar and Hemraj double murder,final arguments in the case began at a sessions court in Ghaziabad on Thursday.
Dentist couple Nupur and Rajesh Talwar are standing trial for the murder of their daughter Aarushi and their domestic help Hemraj on the night of May 15-16,2008.
The final arguments began two days after the Supreme Court said the couple had been adopting dilatory tactics in an attempt to prolong the trial.
On Thursday,the CBI began arguments in the court of ASJ Shyam Lal. Senior CBI prosecutor R K Saini based the final arguments on the accounts of various witnesses dealing with the nature of injures on both victims,the last-seen theory,as well as the conduct of the Talwars on the morning when Aarushis body was discovered.
Saini said,We explained to the court that the case is one based on circumstantial evidence. Based on the accounts of Dr Sunil Dohre and Dr Naresh Raj,who conducted the post-mortem examinations of Aarushi and Hemraj,respectively,we told the court that the injuries on the heads of both victims were made by a golf club. The slits on the throat could have been made by a surgical scalpel or a knife,both of which were easily available at the Talwars residence,the scene of the crime.
The CBI also referred to the examination conducted by D K Tanwar,scientist of the CFSL,who had said two of the golf clubs used seemed cleaner than the others during examination.
The testimony of Umesh,the Talwars driver,was also flagged by the CBI in court. Umesh had confirmed to the court that when he went to the house on the night of May 15,there were only four persons there Rajesh Talwar,Nupur Talwar,Hemraj and Aarushi, the counsel told the court. This ties in with the last-seen theory of the CBI,as Umesh was the last known person to go to the Talwars home before the murders.
The CBI also argued that the conduct of the Talwars on the morning after the murders was suspicious,and based this on the testimonies of Bharti,Sanjay Chauhan,Dr Rohit Kocchar,Mahesh Kumar Mishra and Dattaram Nauneria.
The CBIs arguments will continue on Friday. It is learnt that the final arguments by defence lawyers will be heard after a week,as they may seek time to prepare their case.