Chilled by demonetisation, India to take cold comfort from strong GDP

Narendra Modi expects the cash situation to become normal by end-December, but critics say he is being over-optimistic.

By: Reuters | New Delhi | Updated: November 30, 2016 12:10 pm
narendra modi, demonetisation, india GDP, black money, old Rs 500 note, old Rs 1000 note, currency crisis, september quarter GDP, india GDP rate FILE – In this Nov. 16, 2016 file photo, a man holds a charred facsimile of the discontinued currency 500 note after a protest by a traders association demanding adequate arrangement to exchange discontinued currency notes outside Reserve Bank of India in Kolkata (AP Photo/Bikas Das, File)

India can ill-afford to take much pride in having the world’s fastest growing large economy when it releases September quarter data on Wednesday, with businesses, farmers and families all suffering after the government’s sudden demonetisation drive.

Having taken credit for putting life back in a moribund economy when he took power 2-1/2 years ago, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s crackdown on tax dodgers and counterfeiters by removing 500 rupee and 1,000 rupee banknotes from circulation has taken the economy down a very bumpy road.

How bumpy depends on who’s talking, but almost everyone agrees the drag on growth is likely to last through next year.

WATCH VIDEO: Here’s Why RBI Restricted Withdrawal Limits On Jan Dhan Accounts To Rs 10,000

“The move will weigh on GDP growth for a few quarters, dampening government revenues,” warned credit ratings firm Moody’s Investors Service. “The decline in economic activity will lower corporate sales volumes and cash flows.”

The quarterly gross domestic product data released on Wednesday won’t show the ill-effects. July-September will be the last quarter before the impact is felt from Modi’s bold and risky move this month to force people to deposit their hidden cash in banks, making it easy for the taxman to see.

The median estimate from a Reuters poll showed economists expect economic growth accelerated to 7.5 percent in the September quarter from 7.1 percent in the June quarter.

That’s not as fast as the 7.9 percent posted in the March quarter, but it had recovered momentum, and might have gone higher until Modi launched his attack on the so-called “black economy”.

While Modi has been praised for his intentions, people are wringing their hands over the cost of taking 86 percent of the country’s banknotes out of circulation virtually overnight.

The most optimistic forecasts suggest that India will finish this fiscal year in March with a respectable, but slightly lower growth rate of 7.3 percent.

But the most pessimistic forecast, from Mumbai-based brokerage Ambit Capital, for a precipitous drop to 3.5 percent growth shows just how worried people are.


With a small stock of smaller notes available and new bills of 500 and 2,000 rupee in short supply, Indians had to stand in snaking queues outside banks and cash machines to change their old notes.

The better off may have more money to change, but for the mass of Indian’s living on the margins the disruption and loss of earnings has caused real hardship.

Modi expects the cash situation to become normal by end-December, but critics say he is being over-optimistic.

Meantime, consumers are spending less, which is hurting small producers who, in turn, are being forced to scale back their activities.

As a consequence, supply chains at small, medium and even larger companies are breaking down. Trucks are stranded with no money for fuel, workers won’t load goods for free, and distributors can’t pay up. Wholesale markets in many cities are shut.

The cash crunch has jeopardised production of key commodities and hurt rural communities – just recovering after two years of drought – as farmers lack cash to buy seeds and fertiliser. As a result, the area under cultivation for India’s winter crop has declined.

CMIE, an economic think tank, reckons the big banknote swap would cost at least $19 billion by the end of 2016 in foregone wages, lost business, and higher administrative expenses alone.

The liquidity shortage will retard efforts to revive private investment that has been plagued by weak external demand and a slow recovery in domestic demand.

And, despite the high economic growth rates seen over the past year-and-a-half, factories’ capacity utilization ratio remains stuck near their lowest level since 2009.

“Given that the growth recovery has still not taken full hold, the impact of this demonetisation … could delay the private corporate capex recovery,” analysts at Morgan Stanley wrote in a note, adding that they don’t expect that recovery to happen before 2018.

At least the potential for lower inflation holds out some hope that the Reserve Bank of India will extend its easing cycle with a quick interest rate cut.

“The central bank might prefer to bring forward the rate cut to December to support growth and tap the favourable inflation outlook,” said Radhika Rao, an economist with DBS Bank.

For all the latest Business News, download Indian Express App

  1. H
    Nov 30, 2016 at 8:25 am
    The article is filled by "experts" and "think tanks" who seems to have no idea on the implication of this. What has been done in India has precedence in the world and there are no bench marks available to compare. GDP could fluctuate due to 100s of reasons including demonetization. the government also have implemented with a general planning and day to day issues are being addressed as and when it is come. The fact remains that nobody have starved to death in India because of this nor lack of payment of wages which they are eligible. So what is all these protests all about? It has definitely hurt all political parties including BJP. To start the cleansing in India, somebody have to be tough with the right intentions. Modi is doing that and surprisingly people seems to support him.
    1. S
      Nov 30, 2016 at 9:39 am
      You illiterate don't seem to know anything of Indian politics. Get your statistics before you speak. It makes no sense to educate blind people like you. India under BJP would go down the drain..
      1. A
        ashok s
        Nov 30, 2016 at 4:36 am
        At the end of the day if govt fails , it will incurr a loss of approx 4 trillion in taxes . each year govt collect 14 trillion taxes in various forms . if economy nose drives the loss will minimum of 4 trillion for fy 16-17
        1. A
          ashok s
          Nov 30, 2016 at 4:33 am
          Banks can revolt against govt as they stand to loose 35000 cr in process of demonetization by virtue of interest payments to clients . will stake holder of such banks will bear the loss or customers or govt gives them some relief
          1. A
            ashok s
            Nov 30, 2016 at 4:27 am
            Govt did ber , they killed the cat which was making fears among the rats ,so that they don't disrupt the fields. Now rats are having buffet .
            1. Load More Comments