Cyrus Mistry misled to become chairman, retracted on promises: Tata Sons

Tata Sons on Sunday charged Cyrus P Mistry of misleading to get selected as Chairman, retracting on his promises, concentrating powers and using free-hand given to him to weaken management structures.

By: PTI | New Delhi | Updated: December 11, 2016 8:35 pm
tata group, tata sons, cyrus mistry, ratan tata, tata sons chairman, tata group chairman, tata sons cyrus mistry, business news, india news Ousted Tata chairman Cyrus Mistry. (File Photo)

Escalating the boardroom battle at India’s largest conglomerate, Tata Sons on Sunday charged Cyrus P Mistry of misleading to get selected as Chairman, retracting on his promises, concentrating powers and using free-hand given to him to weaken management structures. Days ahead of meetings of shareholders of group companies to consider removing Mistry from board of key listed companies, Tata Sons said it is bringing out “key facts” that resulted “in the loss of confidence” in him and leading to his removal.

Tata Sons said that Mistry “misled” the Selection Committee set up in 2011 for selecting a Chairman of Tata Sons to succeed Ratan Tata, by “making lofty statements about his plans for the Tata Group and more importantly indicated an elaborate management structure for managing the Tata Group, given its diversity of business, by suggesting a management structure aimed at dispersal of authority and responsibility.”

“These statements and commitments from Mr Cyrus Mistry played an important role in the Selection Committee’s final selection of Mr Mistry as Chairman. After waiting for a period of four years, almost none of these management structures and plans have been given effect to. Clearly, in our opinion, the Selection Committee was misled in its choice of Mr Mistry,” it said. It charged Mistry of “inappropriate” conduct by retracting from his promise to distance himself from his family enterprise – Shapoorji Pallonji & Company to create “a sense of breach of trust” and posing “significant challenge to the high corporate governance principles Tata Sons strived for.”

“This retraction, created grave concerns on Mr Mistry’s ability to lead the Tata Group devoid of personal conflicts and put to risk the high standards of self-less governance, that lies at the core of the Tata philosophy,” it said. Mistry, it said, had over the past 3-4 years concentrated all power and authority only in his own hands as Chairman in all the major Tata Group operating companies and “gone about systematically diluting the representation of Tata Sons on the Boards of various Tata Companies.”

Mistry took advantage of the “free hand” and trust “to weaken management structures in Tata Companies acting contrary to his fiduciary duties,” Tata Sons said in the appeal to shareholders. Tata Sons said its Board has been concerned for some time about the financial performance as the holding company’s dividend income (other than from TCS) declined continuously and staff costs more than doubled.

“All this would have resulted in losses but for the TCS dividend. Mr Mistry did not show concern about these issues and the increasing dependence of Tata Sons on TCS. The Board could not accept this any further as it had the potential to risk the financial viability of Tata Sons,” it said.

Reacting strongly to the Tata’s appeal, Cyrus Mistry said Ratan Tata’s conduct has eroded the Tata brand and values materially. In a statement released, Mistry said, “Repeat a lie thousand times and hope it becomes a truth seems to be Ratan Tata’s last-ditch effort to overcome a monumental disaster his actions unleashed.”

For all the latest Business News, download Indian Express App

  1. N
    N.Sharma
    Dec 11, 2016 at 3:45 pm
    Mistry is being targeted because he is a Parsi. Parsis are the same as aryan brahmins. So BJP should step in and help Cyrus Mistry and maintain the cordial relationship with our Parsi brothers and sisters. Because they are the link between brahmins and their blood-brothers-Israelites.
    Reply
  2. B
    Bhosle
    Dec 11, 2016 at 1:11 pm
    Ratan Tata is dancing to the tunes of lickspittle cl that has occupied the top echelons of his group BY RAW RECOMMENDATIONS THAN BY COMPETENCE. In return for appointing such s as CEOs, Ratan has made mive money in terms of illegal concessions and what not that one can not even imagine. Cyrus Mistry knows if that occupation is allowed, the group is doomed. But alas, a goat believes on butcher.
    Reply
  3. S
    Shekar
    Dec 11, 2016 at 5:38 pm
    Idhar bhi racism, anpad, gawar.
    Reply
  4. S
    stranger
    Dec 12, 2016 at 4:05 am
    tata is spending everything to throw much at cyrus but not a penny to explain the serious charges he raised. don't know if politicians learnt it from them or they learnt it from politicians or a mutual exchange of shared experience. people like mistry are a hope that this business-scam-politics nexus will be broken one day.
    Reply
  5. J
    JJ
    Dec 11, 2016 at 5:20 pm
    Hiring mistake coming to roost.lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Cyrus is probably spilling the beans ... more to me. Can't blame him if you are trying to finish him.
    Reply
  6. S
    sanjay
    Dec 11, 2016 at 2:15 pm
    HOME JOB. JOB. JOBlt;br/gt;WORK WITH DIGITAL INDIAlt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Earn 20,000-50,000 by working 2 hourslt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Without any investmentslt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Write ( JOIN ). WhatsApp no - 7053477053lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;.agvd
    Reply
  7. M
    Mohandas
    Dec 11, 2016 at 3:00 pm
    Never in the history of Tata such a foolish thing of appointing a person like this might have happened even in the category of peon. Such a august house of business which has record in ethical and social high standard is suffering like this person likke this fellow is painful . May be that only deceitful people and business van survive in these new times !
    Reply
  8. N
    Nandu K.
    Dec 11, 2016 at 2:23 pm
    Ratan Tata is a very genuine and straightforward, as a person and as well as a Business man. Let him accept that he made a mistake in selecting a PARSI in leading the prestigious Company of TATAS. On the other hand, Mistry should gracefully step out and concentrate on his congolomerate. There is no meaning in washing dirty linen in the open. In the Corporate world, even today, gracefulness exists. Let them have a close door meeting and agree and issue a joint statement gracefully,
    Reply
  9. Load More Comments