• Associate Sponsor

Agriculture: Union Budget promises MSP 50% above cost, doesn’t define which cost

Whether it is the Budget, the Swaminathan formula or the BJP manifesto, none of them has quite defined what really constitutes “cost of production”. And therein lies the nub.

Written by Harish Damodaran | New Delhi | Updated: February 3, 2018 1:08 pm
During Union Budget 2018 speech, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley announced 50% Minimum Support Price or MSP above cost A farmer working in paddy fields in a village at the outskirts of Punjab on Monday. If 50 per cent-plus returns on A2+FL costs are to be given across the board, the MSP for paddy alone would have to go up from Rs 1,550 to around Rs 1,700 per quintal in the coming kharif season. (Express Photo/Sahil Walia)

The Union Budget for 2018-19 has promised to fix minimum support prices (MSP) for crops to guarantee farmers at least 50 per cent returns on production costs. This is quite similar to the original recommendation of the M S Swaminathan-headed National Commission on Farmers (which called for MSPs to be “at least 50% more than the weighted average cost of production”) and the BJP’s 2014 Lok Sabha Election Manifesto (which talked of ensuring farmers “minimum 50% profits over the cost of production”).

But whether it is the Budget, the Swaminathan formula or the BJP manifesto, none of them has quite defined what really constitutes “cost of production”. And therein lies the nub.

The question assumes importance because the Commission for Agricultural Costs and Prices (CACP), the body that recommends MSPs for various crops, gives three definitions of production costs: A2, A2+FL, and C2.

A2 costs cover actual paid-out expenses incurred by farmers – both in cash and in kind – on seeds, fertilisers, pesticides, hired labour, fuel, irrigation, etc. A2+FL includes A2 plus an imputed value of unpaid family labour.

C2 costs are more comprehensive, accounting for the rentals or interest foregone on owned land and fixed capital assets, on top of A2+FL.

The charts give A2, A2+FL and C2 production costs in 2017-18 for 20 major kharif and rabi season crops, as estimated by the CACP, along with their corresponding MSPs declared by the Centre.

The current MSPs, it can be seen, are more than one-and- a-half times the A2 production in all but three crops: jowar (sorghum), ragi and sunflower. In other words, if it is only about providing 50 per cent return on actual paid-out costs to farmers, that promise has already been met by the Narendra Modi government as far as the MSP announcement goes.

The compliance with the Swaminathan formula, however, drops to just eight out of the 20 crops when it comes to A2+FL costs.

The MSPs are 50 per cent or more than the latter only in bajra (pearl millet), arhar (pigeon pea), urad (black gram), wheat, barley, chana (chickpea), masur (lentil) and mustard.

The compliance is even lower with respect to C2 costs, in which there isn’t a single crop whose MSP is now giving 50 per cent or more return.

The crop coming closest is wheat. With its MSP at 1.38 times the estimated C2 cost, that seems to be the most profitable growing proposition for farmers today.

It’s quite unlikely that the Modi government intends to implement its promise of ensuring minimum 50 per cent profit over production costs in terms of C2. That would entail huge MSPs increases that neither the exchequer nor the markets can bear.

In his Budget speech, Jaitley has noted that the existing MSPs are already at least 1.5 times of production costs “for the majority of rabi crops”. The reference here is clearly to A2+FL costs, as safflower is the only rabi crop whose MSP is not Swaminathan formula-compliant in this case. Jaitley has further stated that his government would raise the MSPs for kharif crops, too, to 1.5 times their production costs.

That, in terms of A2+FL, is now limited only to three kharif crops: bajra, arhar and urad.

If 50 per cent-plus returns on A2+FL costs are to be given across the board, the MSP for paddy alone would have to go up from Rs 1,550 to around Rs 1,700 per quintal in the coming kharif season. That hike – amounting to Rs 150/quintal, as against an average of Rs 60 during the first four years of the Modi government – cannot be ruled out in an election year.

For all the latest Business News, download Indian Express App

  1. U
    Umar
    Feb 4, 2018 at 11:27 am
    Can the IE stop publishing comments of s who do not comment on the subject at hand ? As I can few such guys keep commenting some garbage that they have been fed with and its really annoying.
    (0)(0)
    Reply
    1. C
      Christian Terrorism Buster
      Feb 4, 2018 at 9:22 am
      Child Rapist Christian Church Priest Father Kabat Paul. Accused Oblates of Mary Immaculate Church. Worked in Dioceses of Duluth Christian Church, Crookston Belleville IL and St. Paul-Minneapolis archdiocese. Name released by order in 7/15 as part of 2/15 settlement. Name added 11/3/17 by St. Paul-MInneapolis archdiocese to list of 19 "priests and religious brothers who have served or spent time in the archdiocese and have substantiated claims of sesxual abuse of a minor against them." Left the Oblates in 1989.
      (0)(0)
      Reply
      1. C
        Christian Terrorism Buster
        Feb 4, 2018 at 9:21 am
        Rapist Child Molester Christian Church Padre Jablonowski Anthony. Pleaded guilty to 2004 charges of abuse of 17-yr-old boy in 1982. Sentenced to 15 months to 7 yrs in prison. Privileges removed. Another accuser filed civil suit 3/05. Released from prison 7/05. Required to register as sesx offender christian priest with the local county. Worked in several dioceses and is on Tucson list of abusive priests (refers to him as Steubenville diocese priest). Registered christian priest church rapist offender in FL as of 2010. Had been living in OH.
        (0)(0)
        Reply
        1. C
          Christian Terrorism Buster
          Feb 4, 2018 at 9:21 am
          Church Christian Rapist Priest Father Iannarella James. Accused of abuse of 17 yr old girl for 3 months in 1999. Archdiocese sent him for evaluation and placed him on administrataive leave until 2003. At that time, the archdiocese placed him on inactive status. He worked at Drexel Univ. from 2001-2005 until name appeared on G Jury Report. Another Christian Rapist Priest gets away and no one can do anything as the Christian Church is too powerful mafia and mobster Pope should be going to jail but instead he sits in Vatican and rapes more people.
          (0)(0)
          Reply
          1. C
            Christian Terrorism Buster
            Feb 4, 2018 at 9:21 am
            Father Christian Church Padre Haas Joseph. Haas placed on leave Feb. 2004 after t he molested a young girl in 1977. Haas originally told parish that he was taking leave on doctor's orders but Archbishop sent letter clarifying the situation. Christian DA ruled that 1977 incident was too old to prosecute. Previous allegation of less serious inappropriate behavior was received in 2000 but nothing done. Officially retired Sept. 2004 even though Review Board concluded accusations not substantiated. Pope knew about him but didnt do anything. Monster Christian Priest gets away as Christian Church is too powerful and control the government, media, and the world.
            (1)(0)
            Reply
            1. Load More Comments
            Adda