Why PM Modi should have corrected President Trump when he said ‘Hindus and Indians’

We know Trump is at least semi ignorant, but why did the PMO feel the need to highlight Trump's well known ignorance by repeating his words?

Written by Ujjal Dosanjh | Updated: January 29, 2017 9:07 am
modi-trump-759 The call to Prime Minister Modi by Donald Trump was the fifth he had made to the leaders of other countries; he had called only the leaders of Canada, Mexico, Israel and Egypt before making India his fifth call.

Usually a call from the President of the United States of America to any country and particularly to India, the largest democracy in the world, wouldn’t be something I would write a column about. But the kind of media attention it received in India showed how starved and needy we appear to be for approval, affirmation and reaffirmation from powerful and rich nations. It has happened before. Indian media never stop telling how India was first in this or second in that or third in something else always meaning, implying or stating how it places India ahead of Pakistan, China or some other country. A little competitiveness never hurt a country. But the Indian media seem obsessed with the rankings, particularly as arranged by the rich and powerful nations of the world.

Sure the call to Prime Minister Modi by Donald Trump was the fifth he had made to the leaders of other countries; he had called only the leaders of Canada, Mexico, Israel and Egypt before making India his fifth call. But to media and a leadership of the country possessed of self confidence, being first, fifth or last wouldn’t and shouldn’t matter. But no. The media felt it was worth repeating ad nauseam. All major media establishments were guilty of it. They all made a point of explicitly spelling out how India was called before China, Russia and several others.

In all of this the media made no mention of the fact that Trump, with his campaign under investigation for improper links with Russia, wouldn’t want to be seen to be in any rush to call Putin. His relations with China had already suffered a setback, either deliberately caused or because of the same foolishness that makes him relitigate the crowd size at his inauguration or his ludicrous claim that millions people  fraudulently voted[for which there is absolutely no proof] to deny him the victory in the popular vote. And conveniently the media ignored the fact that Modi has almost Pakistanised India into the lap of US foreign policy. But what the heck! Let’s celebrate: Trump called Modi before Putin, Xijinping and any of the European countries was how it went down.

It was reported that Trump told the Prime Minister that “the US considers India a true friend and partner in addressing challenges around the world”. No wonder here since USA is one of India’s major –foreign policy partners; he also said he “had great confidence in India”–nothing more than the bromides the readouts of the leaders’ conversations are usually replete with.

Something else caught my eye and angered the Indian in me and even more so, the secular Indian. What struck me were the following words in the NDTV report on the matter [and I didn’t see it anywhere else]: “Generations of Hindu and Indian Americans have strengthened our country. Your values of hard work, education and enterprise have truly enriched our nation.” Last October at the Hindu Republican Coalition fundraiser he had promised that in the Whitehouse he will be a friend of “Hindu and Indian community”. And wouldn’t it be absurd if India started referring to the people of the USA as “Christians and the Americans?”

It is not the fault of the foreigners how they describe Indians; the fault is entirely ours and ours alone. Indians abroad constantly, like automatons, telegraph to others that we are Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians, Buddhists and of other faiths first; then Punjabis, Gujaratis, Biharis and whatever else we might be. Rarely are we Indians first in presenting ourselves. Little wonder then that non Indians including leaders continue addressing us as Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims or of other faiths. Wouldn’t it have been a wonderful riposte for Modi to stop Trump in his tracks when in their conversation he said “Hindus and Indians” to correct him:” just as you are not referred to as Christians and Americans, the people of India don’t appreciate being called Hindus and Indians. We are all Indians.” But unfortunately, we all know, Modi may have been quite comfortable being addressed by religion before country.

It is hard to blame Trump for his choice of words; I wouldn’t have expected much sensitivity and awareness from an avowed exclusionist of Mexicans and Muslim. I don’t believe he has much understanding of the American diversity, let alone any appreciation of diversity of India, an ancient nation and civilisation that has been culturally, religiously, ethnically, linguistically and racially diverse from times immemorial.

It was clear from the White House Readout that the words “Hindu and Indian” in the reports on Modi-Trump conversation didn’t originate from the White House. That it must have come from the Indian Readout of the same conversation or some other Indian source must send shock waves through the secular and progressive India. We know Trump is at least semi ignorant. But why did the PMO feel the need to highlight Trump’s well known ignorance by repeating his words? Was it to serve the Hindutva sentiments among the diaspora and in India? If so, that is an unpardonable sin against the idea of India and its secular state. It goes to show that the Modi regime will stop at nothing to sustain and advance the Hindutva agenda.

And noticeably no one in the Indian media will take the Modi government to task for its most insensitive and dangerous act: A matter of great shame.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: January 29, 2017 8:01 am
  1. A
    Al Hindi
    Jan 29, 2017 at 9:32 am
    Every one in Sind and further east are Hindu , until you get the east asians. That everyone knew , the arabs, persians, greeks, chineese and sea faring europeans .lt;br/gt;Donald Trump is right
    Reply
    1. A
      Al Hindi
      Jan 29, 2017 at 9:33 am
      Every one in Sind and further east are Hindu , until you get the east asians. That everyone knew , the arabs, persians, greeks, chineese and sea faring europeans .lt;br/gt;Donald Trump is right
      Reply
      1. I
        indian
        Jan 29, 2017 at 5:03 am
        This article shows that the pseudosecular brigade is grasping foe straws.
        Reply
        1. I
          indian
          Jan 29, 2017 at 5:02 am
          This is utterly ridiculous. Now what Trump says is Modi's fault?
          Reply
          1. A
            Arun
            Jan 29, 2017 at 2:25 pm
            Oye writerlt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Your father is any stani
            Reply
            1. P
              Praveen
              Jan 29, 2017 at 2:03 pm
              Hindus are present elsewhere not just in India
              Reply
              1. I
                India
                Jan 29, 2017 at 7:56 am
                Because stan is the world's most tolerant country
                Reply
                1. I
                  India
                  Jan 29, 2017 at 7:37 am
                  Hindus are respected all over the world this journalist should be wrapped in the box and deported to porkistan
                  Reply
                  1. C
                    Chaman
                    Jan 29, 2017 at 12:14 pm
                    I don't know why some people have allergy with the Hindu word. The writer seems to be one of them
                    Reply
                    1. D
                      DeMon
                      Jan 29, 2017 at 10:14 am
                      Stop Being Ideal.
                      Reply
                      1. %
                        %e0%a4%9c%e0%a4%af %e0%a4%b0%e0%a4%be%e0%a4%ae
                        Jan 29, 2017 at 10:32 am
                        Its only RNDTV which finds seculaism is not being reflected in the speeches of Trump
                        Reply
                        1. B
                          Blue
                          Jan 29, 2017 at 2:51 am
                          Both modi and Trump are modern day Fascist
                          Reply
                          1. B
                            Blue
                            Jan 29, 2017 at 2:52 am
                            Good article thank u for covering this
                            Reply
                            1. G
                              Gurcharanjaswal
                              Jan 29, 2017 at 2:54 am
                              India is hindu country with diversity in religion culture and there is nothing shame if donald trump called india hindu state secularism is a so called political stunt by indian politicians kindly remember that !
                              Reply
                              1. H
                                Hindustan Hamara
                                Jan 29, 2017 at 4:24 am
                                Dear leave aside Muslims, most of Dalit girls are raped suppressed and tortured by the upper caste Hindus. This is fact proven by evidence.
                                Reply
                                1. H
                                  Hindustan Hamara
                                  Jan 29, 2017 at 5:29 am
                                  Hungtington once predicted about clash of civilizations. This clash is very near, All the players on the chess board is now reoriented themselves. New Alignment has formed. Experts predicted Zionist (Corporates and Bankers) vs Rest (Poor and weak). Who wins God Know
                                  Reply
                                  1. H
                                    Hindustan Hamara
                                    Jan 29, 2017 at 5:21 am
                                    I don't understand what do you mean by Hindu where more 30% of the poton of Dalit and Adivasi don't consider themselves Hindu. Sikh and Buddhist consider separate. Dravidian hates Aryan. North East completely Christian. How to consider this country Hindu based on upper caste Hindu dominance? Strength of India is unity in diversity.
                                    Reply
                                    1. H
                                      Hindustan Hamara
                                      Jan 29, 2017 at 3:13 am
                                      Why people pretend to be ignorant? Same forces bring Modi and Trump to the power, isn't it very difficult to understand now. Millions of dollars was spent in election campaign to enter and influence each and every home. From where they got this money? Corporates/Bankers pla vital role? Do they fulfill those promises in election manifesto, big no! Why they got elected, it is because time has come to create new world order. In NWO, countries will be just a piece of land, all power will concentrate in few hands and they will rule through Digital Money/Economy. Demonetization is the preparation in this direction.
                                      Reply
                                      1. I
                                        IML sood
                                        Jan 29, 2017 at 2:55 am
                                        This Cong. stooge sitting outside the country has some underhand dealing with IE as his bias view against the Govt are being given prominent place by IE. A clic and solid example of 'Pressitute' in name of freedom of media.
                                        Reply
                                        1. R
                                          Rik
                                          Jan 29, 2017 at 9:00 am
                                          The author might have been njoying free visa to US and now trumped out....haha...
                                          Reply
                                          1. R
                                            Rik
                                            Jan 29, 2017 at 8:52 am
                                            You are talking about ur self definitely that's makes u so sure of wat u wrote....
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments